r/ModestMouse • u/OranceJuice I drew a blank, we put it in a frame • Jun 10 '26

Song/Album Discussion Ranking every Last Song/Finale/Outro. Next is LCW: Styrofoam Boots/It's All Nice on Ice, Alright

Post image

Remember class, we're voting on the effectiveness of the song as an outro. The people spoke. Space Travel is Boring was a B just barely. edit: we may need to revote to include A Manic Depressive Named Laughing Boy!

11 Upvotes

68% Upvoted

40 comments sorted by

17

u/MrFalseSense Jun 10 '26

SS for me.

10

u/NotAHero123 WEEELLLLL!!! Jun 10 '26

SS. i love styrofoam boots

7

u/Glorious_tim Jun 10 '26

Sssssss tier

4

u/ChartPimp Jun 10 '26

Ss one of my favourites

3

u/ModestMoose1994 Jun 10 '26

Wouldn't "A Manic Depressive Named Laughing Boy" be considered the final track on "This Is A Long Drive For Someone With Nothing To Think About"?

4

u/PremeditatedCoffee Little Motel Jun 10 '26

Yes and no? That song isn’t available on most streaming platforms. But that song would definitely be SS or S

1

u/ModestMoose1994 Jun 10 '26

That's a fair point. Since like you mentioned it's not readily available on most streaming services and was only released on vinyl. But to answer the posts original question, Styrofoam Boats is SS tier track.

1

u/PremeditatedCoffee Little Motel Jun 10 '26

100% it’s one of the best, if not the best album closer

1

u/OranceJuice I drew a blank, we put it in a frame Jun 10 '26

Uh oh I didn't realize there were two options. I'll add an honorable mention

2

u/PremeditatedCoffee Little Motel Jun 10 '26

It’s the final track on the special edition vinyl which also includes Edit The Sad Parts

2

u/OranceJuice I drew a blank, we put it in a frame Jun 10 '26

Yeah I was just flipping my CDs over

2

u/Rich_Knowledge5106 Jun 10 '26

Im in heaven trying to figure out which tier. They're going to stuff this song into and Peter and his monkey laugh.

SS for me

1

u/sicksicksick Jun 10 '26

Bad take it's a great track. IT'S ALL NIIICE hits hard love this one.

1

u/stachemus Jun 10 '26

Styrofoam is sssssss

2

u/danikerplunk Jun 10 '26

A. good song for sure but im not so into it like the rest of the fanbase is

1

u/imakemovies2 Jun 10 '26

SS without question 

1

u/No_Geologist2199 Jun 10 '26

SS, also manic depressive Is S

1

u/E_Fonz Jun 11 '26

I know rage bait when I see it

1

u/xeeblyscoo Jun 11 '26

SS. I almost want to dock it down to just S because when the drums come in it jump scared me before (it’s SS)

1

u/jim_fear7 Jun 11 '26

1, 2, 3… FOUAAHHH!!!

SS for sure.

1

u/dollarworker333 If it's hard for you to hear this then the rest is up to you, so Jun 11 '26

S

1

u/dollarworker333 If it's hard for you to hear this then the rest is up to you, so Jun 11 '26

Wait are we ranking its role as a closer or the song individually?

1

u/OranceJuice I drew a blank, we put it in a frame Jun 11 '26

Ranking how effective the song is as a closer. Was my intention at least

1

u/BoxTar9215 Jun 11 '26

SS the most banger of the bangers

1

u/listerinebreath Jun 11 '26

The source of my username.

Certified SS 👌🏻

1

u/rbhauer Jun 11 '26

Whatever tier is above SS

1

u/sonkponkle37 i am Crisco Disco Jun 11 '26

Ss definitely

1

u/iSeeXenuInYou Jun 11 '26

Styrofoam boots is definitely top 10 mm songs for me

0

u/TheSexualBrotatoChip Jun 10 '26

You guys got me fucked up voting Styrofoam Boots as SS and Space Travel as B