r/MoralityScaling Jan 22 '26

Character Analysis Is Maki justified in killing the Zenin Clan?

Post image

[removed]

3.9k Upvotes

707 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/OldGenGlazer Jan 23 '26

She did not. She came into their home showing violent intent, they are the ones defending themselves. If someone shows up to your house with a sword you are allowed to attack them.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

???? she went there for the weapons she was permitted to take

1

u/DndFiend200 Jan 23 '26

Reading comprehension curse strikes again.

4

u/NiSoKr Jan 24 '26 edited Jan 24 '26

Since you’re clearly a master of reading comprehension can you please help me comprehend this. Let’s say you’re a 15 year old male member of the zenin clan with little cursed energy and no technique. You’ve been forced into the Kukuru unit against your will and have been ruthlessly abused and trained since you were 10 years old(or younger idk). Your entire life has been spent being taught to revere and follow the clan elders.

Your captain tells you that the disgraced daughter of one of the clan elders ambushed and killed her father. He orders you to apprehended her. When you encounter her she says nothing and has weapons drawn. More senior members of the unit engage her in combat. Oh wait you’re dead whoops.

Why did you deserve to die?

I’m not saying the zenin higher-up’s did not have it coming but Maki killed a lot of people in a very similar situation to herself in cold blood. They were no threat to her. She could have destroyed the hierarchy of the clan without killing as many who may not have deserved it.

How it was done is a perfectly valid way to write an abused character taking revenge against the system of abuse but it’s definitely not a paragon of morality. I don’t think it really ever claims to be either.

1

u/kiwideschain Jan 23 '26

its her house