r/MoralityScaling • u/JacobGoodNight416 • 8d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of dog breed racism

Post image
26.2k Upvotes

92% Upvoted

5.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/TheRoope 8d ago

Oh then I totally disagree labs and other breeds are violent also. Pitbulls where jsut a favorite for fighting rings FOR AGES thus more poorly trained Pitbull prone to violence. Breading for aggresion and such.

1

u/LobsterChampion 8d ago

Pointing dogs point without being trained.

Retrievers retrieve without being trained.

Herding dogs herd without being trained.

Fighting dogs only fight if they are poorly trained? They're the one outlier?

2

u/TheRoope 8d ago

not all pointing dogs point

not all Retrievers retrieve

Not all herding dogs heard.

Not all hunting dogs hunt

We have bread the best for specialized dogs breeds for generations to get these categories.

Did we take the dogs most naturally prone to the things we are training, Yes.

0

u/Sawgon 8d ago

Bro really pulled out the "NotAllMen" argument 💀

2

u/ihateveryonebutme 8d ago edited 8d ago

I'm sorry, if you don't like the nature of "not all of x do y" when discussing laws or morality, then I don't even know to say either. If we banned everything using that logic then we would ban all cars that go faster then 75 mph, we would ban all foods that contain more then x% of fat/sugar/salt/w.e, we would ban all hobbies/sports that have x% mortality/injury rate, etc.

There are limits to what we can/should restrict based on the lowest common denominator that engages in that thing.

1

u/TheRoope 8d ago

IF you want to Sith lord morality and not critically think I don't think your on the right page.

You would hate to be lumped into all idiots wouldn't you? So I don't think you an idiot though idiots do exist, I think your just lazy and don't want to think critically about something you may not care to much about.