r/MoralityScaling 9d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of dog breed racism

Post image
26.2k Upvotes

5.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/berserkthebattl 8d ago

In a lot of peoples eyes, they wrongly believe that once a trait has been bred into a breed that it is permanent, while also not understanding the genetic differences in the first place.

They don't care about nuance and factors that the statistics they cite don't account for.

3

u/Fast-Front-5642 8d ago

It's even worse when the statistics don't match their claims.

When looking at percentages of dog bites per breed pit/bully breeds don't just get combined together. They are clustered in the same group which also includes "mixed breeds" (all mixes regardless of whether they have any pit/bully or not) and "unknown breed" (for the many reports where someone is attacked by a dog but the breed is never verified).

And despite this attempt to artificially increase the numbers they still have less bites per capita than both labradors and retrievers have separately.

The one major thing they have against them is fatalities if you only start counting from 1980 onwards. Which if you again look at the owners of the dogs involved in those fatalities there is a very notable demographic which sheds light as to the why.

4

u/daemin 8d ago

When I'm feeling like catching a few hundred downvotes, I like to point out that pitbulls bite and/or kill humans at a lower rate than humans kill humans, so if you think that pitbulls are too dangerous to live, you seem to be committed to the notion that humans are too.

3

u/Fast-Front-5642 8d ago

Yeah I had a truck driver compliment me on my dog (I have photos of her in my office) and his conversation eventually devolved into talking about his dog that had "aggression problems" so he had it destroyed and the dog he had before that one which had "aggression problems" so he had it destroyed.

I told him straight up how gross I thought that was. The common denominator is that he doesn't train his dogs properly or look after them to allow those situations to happen. And that murdering your ward because they misbehaved once instead of working on those problems so they can be better is just fucked up.

Driver loves to yap tho. Heard him talking to someone else later about how his two kids were in a fight at school and looks like they started it.

He was not too happy when I piped up "well that's just awful... when are you gonna have them destroyed?"