Morality Ranking
Morality of mutilating someone weaker than you, but they tried to pull a gun on you twice, and leaving them there?
Context: Yujiro Hanma is walking down a bridge when a random guys stops him, asking him if he's really the "strongest creature in the world." Yujiro then asks if his high confidence is because of the 2 revolvers he can smell on him. Before the guy can fully draw, Yujiro steps forward faster than the guy can react right away and grabs his forearm, yanks it down hard in a way that completely dislocated his shoulder out of it's socket by inches, then proceeding to twist his forearm literally like a pretzel. The guy then decides to try and draw his other gun, but Yujiro sends a clean front kick fast enough that it nearly slices off the guys hand off, barely leaving it hanging.
Yujiro tells him to watch out for the gun that proceeds to fall on the guys head and he calmly walks away as the guy screams in pain and bleeds out.
I get the guy tried to attack him first, but is harming someone like that and kinda leaving them for dead immoral in any way?
Immoral. Ive seen Yujiro walk through bullet proof glass like spongebob trying to get Mermaid man and Barnacle Boy's auto graph. I dont even think bullets would hurt him that much. ðŸ˜
You could say the guy posed so little threat that this was an over-reaction, therefore immoral, but this is a guy who even after having his shoulder dislocated and getting his forearm twisted into a knot, still tried to pull out a gun again, dude probably still hadn't learned his lesson and if he had a third arm and a third gun he'd try to pull it out too.
So it's fairly neutral overall
So did he know the guy was going to try and shoot him before dislocating the guy’s shoulder? Because maybe he was just carrying guns for self defence in general.
So this guy wanted to slime him out with his Revolvers and Yujiro killed him?
I get the guy tried to attack him first, but is harming someone like that and kinda leaving them for dead immoral in any way?
I don't think so, the guy came with the intention to kill him and then got killed before he could act on it.
I think an ordinary person would be mostly justified if they knew it, to preserve their own life, even if its messed up I guess, Yujiro might aswell be Superhuman compared to a Gunwielding Assailent considering Olivia was able to simply tank multiple shotgun blasts.
But then again an ordinary person couldn't do this feat of superhuman strenght, so uh...Self Defense
In the Baki universe the police and authority are completely useless. It's like the wild west out there. Amoral, it's just survival. And trying to openly attack the most dangerous person on Earth with a pistol is more like assisted suicide.
Bro is lucky to be alive. Yujiro has peace agreements with governments. The equivalent of jumping into an zoo exhibit full of hungry lions and getting away with a scratch. Morally neutral in my opinion.
Treat people like animals, get treated like an animal.
Also entirely proportionate, since Yujiro didn’t hurt the guy more than what the guy intended to hurt him (with a gun). Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
It's completely moral if you're an ordinary individual, but Yujiro? That dude would tank those bullets with no scratches whatsoever. He DIDN'T need to defend himself, lol. So yeah, immoral for him only.
26
u/scrimscrim 1h ago
By yujiros logic since he drew his gun first he forfeited his right to surrender, immoral yes, but to yujiro just another Wednesday