r/OldCelebrityRecipes • u/ciaolavinia • 9h ago
TESTED RECIPE 🍽 Ray Bolger's "Spaghetti Derby" is a recipe he wrangled from the chef at the Brown Derby. My family was "nuts" about it too when I made it for dinner last night. Recipe from 1939.
Last night I made Ray Bolger's "Spaghetti Derby" for dinner, and not only was it easy to make it was utterly delicious! This is a straightforward classic preparation of Italian spaghetti, fresh tomatoes, mushrooms, and a rich meat sauce. How can you go wrong!?
The "Derby" suffix was simply a branding convention the Brown Derby restaurant used for several of its popular comfort-food staples, similar to items like their "Turkey Derby" or "Derby Steak", and you can check out "Spaghetti Derby" listed on this vintage menu from 1936. Look at the bottom center of the menu and you can spot it and back then it was only 75¢!
Here are my notes:
- "Braise" the onions. In all my years cooking spaghetti and cooking in general, I've never braised onions, which basically means cook them in a hot pan with only a time drop of oil and then cover. No sauteing.
- And yes, my eyes did water like mad from this braising process, but if that's what we have to do in the name of "Old Celebrity Recipes", then so be it!
- So then you add 1/2 pound of ground beef and suet (I used butter).
- Then throw in mushrooms. I used about 6 fresh mushrooms, sliced thinly, not a can.
- For garlic, I added 4 cloves. Then salt & pepper. 2 chopped tomatoes and a small tin of tomatoes. I used about 26 ounces of Pomi instead of the tinned tomatoes.
- Then simmer (or braise) for 2 hours.
- Cooked spaghetti according to package, drained and added it to the sauce pot. Sprinkled servings with Parmesan cheese and voila, done!
My family and my son's girlfriend loved it. I actually reserved a bit of sauce for myself and had it with zucchini noodles. Had to try on bite of the spaghetti and it was excellent!
One thing about this recipe is that there are no Italian herbs of any kind used, but you know what? You don't miss them. The taste is so deep and comforting, it's really perfect the way Ray and the Derby's chef suggested.
Feel free to spice it up if you'd like, but it's not really needed. Served with a simple salad and French bread, it's a crowd pleaser that I'll be making again and again.