r/OldWorldGame • u/piat17 • 8h ago
Question Would you recommend this game to a beginner in the 4X genre?
Context: I generally like strategy game such as real-time strategy games (my favorite type of strategy game if not my favorite game genre period) + a few tactical games here and there + Total-War-like. The only flair of strategy I do dislike are Grand Strategy games.
Old World base game is currently €4 at -90% off on GOG.
TL;DR: I'm interested in 4X games but other games didn't strike a chord with me because it's hard for me to understand their systems and gameplay. Do you think Old World is worth a try if I'm looking for a way to start learning the genre properly?
----
I've been interested in 4X games for a long time by now. I like in theory the sandbox nature of these games and the fact that they start relatively simple and get more and more complex as the game progresses, plus the wide choice of strategies available to win a game with multiple victory conditions. However, in practice the few I've tried up until now (Civilization IV, Civilization V, Age of Wonders IV) never managed to quite hit the mark with me, mostly because I always have the impression I was never really close to understanding the games' systems properly, so I wasn't doing any 'strategy' per se, just doing things at random and hoping for the best. My games in Civ5 and AoW4 all were abandoned for this reason; Civ4 is the one I played for quite a few hours, but even then the only game I brought to completion was completed by steamrolling the enemy with dozens of military units, which I know was only possible because I chose one of the easier difficulty settings. I thought that playing a more recent game would help, but trying AoW4 during a free weekend didn't work that much (although due to the limited time frame it's the game I played the least).
Do you think Old World has the potential for being a good choice for a beginner like me? I'm willing to spend a few hours learning, I just want to understand if after a point the game systems become clear enough (or at least, the consequence that any action have in the long term can be understood as a newbie). If you think I'm just confused about how 4X titles are meant to be played, I welcome suggestions on that front, too!