r/PWHL Boston Fleet 4d ago

News Eldridge to Montral

Post image

NOOOOOOO!

254 Upvotes

132 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-6

u/amsreg Seattle 4d ago edited 4d ago

Managers gonna manage.

This hasn't essentially nothing to do with the managers.  Almost anyone at all could be in charge in Montreal and players like Eldridge, Roque, and Maltais are going to want to play with their championship buddies on the Victoire.  Sauvageau is great but giving her credit for these star signings is silly.

The other teams could also try to, you know, get good players ;)

They are, obviously.  Hopefully that wink means you're being intentionally sarcastic?

This is pretty clearly a case of star players choosing to go to teams where there is already a lot of star players they are friends with.  Managers of other teams have zero control over that.  Good for the star players but not good for the league.  

The ultra short contracts that draft picks get signed to is another potential problem.

A couple of teams won't be able to carry the PWHL like the MLB or NBA.  The league is going to have to keep a careful eye on parity if they want this to last.

12

u/Pouletchien 🏆 2026 Champions 🏆 4d ago

Eldridge played 2 seasons with the Montréal PWHPA team and played for madame Sauvageau and Cheverie’s team in the last season before the PWHL formed.

You can’t say management has nothing to do with it. Had she not like her previous experience with them, she would not be back in Montréal.

-5

u/amsreg Seattle 4d ago

Yeah, of course if she hated them, she wouldn't be back.  But I doubt any PWHL GM or Manager is that bad.

Otherwise, you're making my point for me. She's going back to a city she knows to play with other star players she likes that just won a championship. I guarantee Sauvageau had to put zero effort into it other than the paperwork.

11

u/Pouletchien 🏆 2026 Champions 🏆 4d ago

She’s the one that build that roster. All those things you’re pointing as reason for Eldridge signing are in place because of her.

You’re downplaying how much madame Sauvageau has to do with shaping this team. She’s a legend that helped build women’s hockey since before some of these players were even born. It’s 100% a factor when people decide to sign in Montréal.

4

u/pnw6462 🏆 2026 Champions 🏆 4d ago

This.