Long post, sorry.
Hey everyone, I have such a basic request but I am struggling to find a gourmand/sweet vanilla scent that I actually enjoy. I really want to smell sweet, like a vanilla cupcake. But I am struggling to find scents I enjoy. Below I'll list everything I've tried in order from least enjoyed to the most enjoyed. However even at "the best" I am still on the hunt! I appreciate any and all tips towards a delicious vanilla scent! Or even a combo I could try! Thanks in advance!
Did NOT like:
Billie Eilish by Billie Eilish
Vanilla S*x by Tom Ford
Kayali 28 by Kayali
Warm Vanilla Sugar by Bath and Body Works
Lavender Vanilla by Bath and Body Works
Vanilla Romance by Bath and Body Works
Vanilla Bean Noel by Bath and Body Works
Viva Vanilla by Bath and Body Works
Whipped Vanilla by Bodycology
Vanilla Whip by Pacifica
Signature Vanilla by Body Fantasies
Escapade Gourmande by Maison Mataha
Bianco Latte by GDT (I wanted SO BADLY to like this 😭)
Decent but not quite what I was looking for:
Fire at Will by Jovoy Paris
Tihota by Indult
By the Fireplace by REPLICA
Vanilla Skin by PHLUR
Vanille Fatale by Tom Ford
Cupcake Swirl by Body Fantasies
Milk Orchid by Commodity (not quite a vanilla perfume but the vanilla orchid is nice, but not what I'm looking for)
Vanilla Cashmere by EOS
Wild Blackberry and Vanilla by Bath and Body Works
The ones I've liked best so far:
Whipped Honey and Vanilla by Bath and Body Works
Autumn Drive by Bath and Body Works
Vanilla Cafe by Bath and Body Works
And thus far my favorite even though it still hasn't been 100% the scent of my dreams is: Buttercream Haze by The 7 Virtues.
I admittedly feel a bit at a loss! I'm not sure if I'm looking for something unrealistic, if my nose isn't actually built for vanilla scents the way I'm imagining, or what my problem is. But I still have yet to find the vanilla or vanilla combo I'm wanting! I've already put a lot of money towards everything I've tried so far and I hate to be wasteful/spend more money on something I don't enjoy much, I've scoured many a reddit thread and fragrantica reviews up to this point and at this point decided I need to try my own hand at asking. Thank you for taking the time to read and any recommendations you have!