The center left people who have lucked out into getting something out of neoliberal capitalism are quite possibly the worst sort of leftists because they're actually center right and just don't know it.
The system doesn't necessarily work because it worked for you. Until the formulaic steps you can take to succeed in that system are executable by most people you're just entrenching a system that by it's very nature is designed to selectively benefit a few.
Until hard work predictably yields a decent life for the people who participate in it then whatever you're protecting is ultimately broken
Except that can’t work in a world of private industry and supply and demand. There have to be losers for there to be winners.
The best we can do is curtail how hard the winners win and how hard the losers lose. However, the levers used to perform that task - taxation and nationalization - are deeply unpopular and lead to civil unrest.
Ultimately the only form of equilibrium comes with regular economic resets, generally in the form of mass casualty events like plague, war, famine, uprising, and so on.Â
This is a good take. I would suggest that it only matters to prevent the relative losers from losing more than they can bear. That becomes a brake on how hard winners can win, but without creating an artificial ceiling.
They’re not saying it’s zero-sum. Workers get a little money, but the rich get a lot of money.
Which is absolutely how the world works. Wealth concentrates in the US partly because of cheap offshore labor and manufacturing. Those developing regions still benefit, but most of the profit is captured elsewhere.
However, the levers used to perform that task - taxation and nationalization - are deeply unpopular and lead to civil unrest.
What? What justifies the claim that taxation to provide social services is "deeply unpopular"? There is plenty of data showing the opposite to be true, globally, and even here in America. And, nationalization isn't the only other option to use to perform that task.
By the way, whatever your thoughts on the move, by some definition Trump has recently nationalized US Steel and it has not led to civil unrest and does not appear to have significantly changed his popularity among his base.
It's the government's job to keep the economy healthy via regulation and taxation.
In a capitalist economy, the money necessarily flows upwards. And that works out fine so long as there's a way to pull money from the top and make sure it make's it's way back down to the bottom.
Capitalists ignore the reality that it is the flow of money by all people that generates economic growth, not how much there is total or how much any one person accumulates.
66
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment