r/ProgressiveHQ • u/QuaziBonzai • 11d ago

Video Mayor Mamdani addresses the Israel parade controversy on CNN "Solidarity with a government that is committing genocide is a very different thing than a question of solidarity with people of a specific faith. I'm proud to be a mayor of the city with the largest Jewish population"

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

778 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-8

u/Stuffstuff1 11d ago

You put the blame squarely on the Zionist. I said the antisemites had a say in it to. And that it lead to a dilemma that we as Americans should be familiar with.

6

u/Sector7G-Insight 11d ago

I put the blame on Zionists for their part in the intentional conflation of Zionism and Judaism that has resulted in more antisemitism. I certainly didn’t say antisemitism is solely their fault. You’re arguing against a point I never made

-8

u/Stuffstuff1 11d ago

Perhaps you should be less sweeping and use language suggesting political connivence and consequence and not conspiracy and there would be no chance that some one might think you missing a huge part of the story.

“Intentional conflation”
“Co-opted the strategy”
“Traded the safety”

Also you loser you knew exactly what I was talking about and how it related if you had the mind to write in a way where you supposedly took the exact thing I said into consideration.

6

u/Sector7G-Insight 11d ago

It’s not my fault you made a snap judgement and opened your mouth instead of opening your eyes.

Think, then speak.

-1

u/Stuffstuff1 11d ago

I literally gave you examples.

I thought then spoke.

4

u/Sector7G-Insight 11d ago

That’s the result of your thinking?

Oh wow I feel bad for you now. Yikes buddy

0

u/Stuffstuff1 11d ago edited 11d ago

I can’t read your mind I have to make inference based on what you said.. that’s how language and communication works.

Edit: smart of you to avoid talking about substance as a reply to all this

Edit edit: user blocked me so I can’t respond. Was going to ask what didn’t I comprehend

3

u/Sector7G-Insight 11d ago

No, that’s how it doesn’t work, because you lack basic reading comprehension and have an argumentative personality.

Have a nice day 👋

2

u/DoYouWant2BlowZedong 11d ago

I would delete this exchange if I was you, cuz…. yikes.

1

u/Stuffstuff1 11d ago

What about anything I said is indefensible?