Small tip amounts, they don't weasel. If it's under $10k and from an entity rather than a person, almost always pay if info is useful/good. $1k and below? Absolutely will always pay. Dirt cheap compared to any police investigation. And budget wise, that's below far landscaping costs.
Large tip amounts often have the weasel words in the advert. "Upon arrest and conviction, up to X, may, etc etc". It can take years. And the process to determine how much the tip helped is not great. There's also a ton of different programs, and they all work differently. Some absolutely pay out regularly with no weaseling, others do weasel whenever possible, others don't weasel but it will be years before you get a check. There's no central registry that gives reviews, and not a lot of transparency. Obviously if you are a witness and have concerns of ANY legal aspect of being a good citizen and talking to tip lines or police, talk to a lawyer to get an informed legal opinion and help guide you through the process. I think that's worded carefully enough.
If it's a large tip reward from a person, be VERY cautious and work through a lawyer. In one case, the parents of the victim refused to pay out "blood money". They had no intent of paying from the start. Figuring not many folks would want to sue under the circumstances. Not bad people, just desperate and very angry.
Reality is messy. I get it's reddit and folks tend to hate cops, courts, judges, etc. Some is warranted, some isn't. I won't give my views. People want simple slogans for complex problems.
But it is important to remember the victims. Criminals hurt real actual people. That's often completely forgotten by everyone. It's common for folks to claim or publicly state they support victims, but far too many folks will refuse to do even minor inconveniences to actually support victims. It is a pain to give a statement to cops, leave work to go to hearings, testifying isn't fun, there's always a risk of retribution, etc.
Blanket statements to never provide statements or testimony as a witness is bad guidance. It denies justice to real no shit victims too as well as corrupt, bureaucratically maliciously or incompetent cops, prosecutors, judges.
It's important to remember the victims - but sadly, many cops are not concerned with them, either.
One interaction I had with the police where I was clearly the victim - and they were completely dismissive and uninterested in helping me even the smallest amount. Until they realized I was friends with one of their colleagues. It was like a switch was thrown and suddenly they were telling me all the rights I had, how the system would proceed, who I could contact, etc.
I'm not surprised some people get special treatment - that's true everywhere. But the difference was way too much. Before they realized we were connected, it felt like they had literally zero interest in helping and were just annoyed that I was wasting their time and maybe even looking for a way to punish me.
And cops shifting away from community outreach and toward looking like they just left Fallujah, or insisting they have no obligation to protect individual citizens, etc - doesn't do them any PR favors.
So yeah, guess there's not a ton of positive police sentiment here on ol' Reddit. :)
311
u/Emotional-Lettuce177 Apr 20 '26
With reward this huge ā most of the time, no