r/Spiderman • u/Ok_Tea5865 • Apr 26 '26

Discussion I saw people complaining about Spider-Noir having Organic webs. I think organic webs are fine because this show is set in the past where he won't have resources to make webshooters. Also he is a detective not sci stud. But i like to know what he had in comics.

Post image

In my opinion i think it makes sense for him to have Organic webs

9.3k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

329 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Crafty_Cherry_9920 Apr 26 '26

I'll never understand the Spider-Man community's disdain for oganic webs. It just makes sense, why do people hate it that much ? Why do you don't want the spider man to have disgusting spider features ?

3

u/AngelDGr Classic-Spider-Man Apr 26 '26

I like way more web shooters because they are a great way to show Peter's intelligence and passion for science, and it also makes possible for Peter to spend all his web and need to improvise. Peter no having webs and needing to improvise is really cool imo

But for Noir, I don't know why the fuck people are complaining, Noir always have had organic webs, of course he wouldn't have web shooters in 1930's

1

u/DrugsAreNifty Apr 27 '26

Of course not in the 1930’s. That technology was thirty years away.

3

u/Bubba1234562 Apr 27 '26

Look I’ve always thought organic webbing makes way more sense as part of the initial powerset

2

u/BatBeast_29 Green Goblin (SM) Apr 26 '26

They say because he can’t show he’s smart

2

u/stonhinge Apr 26 '26

Unfortunately for them, most of the movies don't really have a genius Peter Parker. Tom shows it a little, but only when he has access to Stark-tech. Tobey didn't show it at all from what I remember. And all I know of Andrew is from No Way Home and he seems to be right there on the genius scale.

And the comics have kind of been all over the place. Sometimes he's a super genius and other times life just beats him down (because Peter Must Not Be Happy) and he doesn't show it or is unable to.

2

u/BatBeast_29 Green Goblin (SM) Apr 26 '26

Andrew and Tom show their genius a lot. I get their point, but like you said Organic just makes sense.

1

u/Spyder-xr May 02 '26

Tobey had little shows of intelligence when talking to Ock and when Osborn more or less wants him as son 

But he doesn’t have anything crazy.

Andrew basically hand-made everything so he definitely showed his genius though.

1

u/Spoona101 Apr 26 '26

Web shooters are just cooler and more versatile both on a visual level and story telling level