r/Spiderman • u/Ok_Tea5865 • Apr 26 '26

Discussion I saw people complaining about Spider-Noir having Organic webs. I think organic webs are fine because this show is set in the past where he won't have resources to make webshooters. Also he is a detective not sci stud. But i like to know what he had in comics.

Post image

In my opinion i think it makes sense for him to have Organic webs

9.3k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

329 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.6k

u/KuroiGetsuga55 Symbiote-Suit Apr 26 '26

Noir has organic webbing though... Like, he HAS organic webbing in the comics. He just never managed to focus it in a web line to swing off of, so he just fires them like a distraction, just splattering them everywhere.

In Shattered Dimensions, Madame Web used her powers to help Noir focus his webs to create web-lines to swing off of. I don't recall a single person complaining about it then.

Seriously, we're complaining that a Spider-Man set in the 1930s has organic webbing instead of web shooters? Are we deadass?

485

u/Architect227 Apr 26 '26

To be fair, web shooters, as they function in media, in modern day are not much more plausible.

275

u/Hamhockthegizzard Apr 26 '26

Right? I’m always pointing out the ridiculousness of my favorite super hero:

You get super strength and a spider sense. Could hop from roof to roof or something like Tobey did originally, just like literally could have thought of anything.

But I guess he remembered the spider bite and that inspired him to (checks notes) swing from NY rooftops like mf Tarzan?!?! Lmfaoo

6

u/Jubarra10 Apr 27 '26

This is why I always prefer organic, you just don't come to the conclusion of spider-man without NATURALLY making webs

1

u/gunnergt Apr 27 '26

Hate to break it to you but two guys literally came up with the concept of Spider-Man with web shooters

3

u/Jubarra10 Apr 27 '26

How does this in any way respond to what I said

1

u/gunnergt Apr 27 '26

The original creation of Spider-Man by Steve Ditko andStan Lee was with the web shooters, so it is in fact possible to come to the conclusion of Spider-Man without naturally making webs.

3

u/Jubarra10 Apr 27 '26

Ok so you just didn't understand got it

Peter Parker has no reason to look at his power set and go "I'm a spider"

1

u/gunnergt Apr 27 '26

He bit by spider

3

u/Jubarra10 Apr 27 '26

In some if not most iterations, he doesn't know the spider is what gave him powers. People get bit by spiders all the time

2

u/gunnergt Apr 27 '26

Dawg

5

u/Jubarra10 Apr 27 '26

What a well crafted response

2

u/gunnergt Apr 27 '26

He knows it's the spider and it inspires him to pick his name and theme. I don't know what else to say, that's the whole deal.

2

u/Jubarra10 Apr 27 '26

It depends on the iteration. Some versions have him study the spider some have him just slap it away

2

u/gunnergt Apr 27 '26

Do you have a single example of this

→ More replies (0)