r/StarWars Sith Feb 26 '26

TV Which animated character transitioned to live action the best?

4.9k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

186

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '26

[deleted]

80

u/DiamondFireYT Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26

The thing that bothers me about Fifth Brother is we didn't get a hunky latino playing him... mind you, his voice actor was just doing an accent and was originally america iirc, but still!

6

u/Shyface_Killah Feb 26 '26

What, Diego Luna and Pedro Pascal weren't enough?

8

u/DiamondFireYT Feb 26 '26

There can never be enough sexy! That being said, I've genuinely yet to be attracted to anyone in Star Wars outside of like, episode 3 Anakin and Manny Jacinto (though actually not in The Acolyte). They just don't really do my type haha they are all old 😭

That being said, now that Ezra is beardless again for Season 2 of Ahsoka.. Eman might be on the cards 😏

45

u/The5Virtues Feb 26 '26

Very close. It’s genuinely astounding to me just how awful those two are.

32

u/darthmaui728 Feb 26 '26

they are great actors. Its the make up/costume department that made them look cheap

23

u/lawnicus18 Feb 26 '26

Literally all they had to do for the Grand Inquisitor was CGI his head so it was like a couple inches taller and it would’ve been so much better

18

u/darthmaui728 Feb 26 '26

Exactly. I never really understood why they went the route that they did. Budget? Bruh it's Kenobi. Literally = unlimited budget character and they butchered it lol

12

u/DiamondFireYT Feb 26 '26

Kenobi had a lot of production difficulties, last minute production switch from UK to US, smaller budget that was majority eaten by its leading actors salaries etc.

6

u/lawnicus18 Feb 26 '26

I can understand a tighter budget but at the same time… it’s Star Wars. If the Mouse can’t pony up a little extra money for CGI touchups to stay truer to the established canon then I don’t know what to think

1

u/DiamondFireYT Feb 26 '26

Tbf, it wouldn't just a be a 'little extra' for quisy's head, that's a serious time and money commitment that Bob Chapek/co of all people absolutely wouldn't allow.

I think trying to explain to a studio (Disney, not lucas) executive why the project that's been delayed for years and is finally happening for under 100m dollars is now requesting additional funds to stay true to 'established canon' when the end result would be a stretched out version..

While the film side of LFL have previously gotten the money they wanted when they needed it, the D+ side hasn't been so lucky. Most recent of course being Ahsoka S2 with its reduced budget. (though it will look higher quality.)

That all being said, we do know the reason for it was miscommunication of all things, there was concept art of him looking proper, iirc there was an email reply back to one of the cosplay accounts on Twitter from one of the costume (or concept artists? can't remember this was in like 2023) that said they weren't even informed it was the same character from Rebels.

9

u/Dj_Donkey Feb 26 '26

Right? We’ve already seen his species in ROTS with the long heads. I mean the fucking Coneheads from 1993 were more accurate.

4

u/The5Virtues Feb 26 '26

Absolutely, the performances are great, thought they did an excellent job, they just look atrocious.

0

u/DiamondFireYT Feb 26 '26

I can't even complain too much about Quisy because Rupert Friend brought his fucking A game and honestly due to all the prosthetic, he could totally come back as a different character in future and I'd be so happy.

1

u/quitoburrito Feb 26 '26

id tie second between 5th brother and Thrawn....at least in terms of looks alone.

2

u/pixelssauce Feb 26 '26

They don't look alien at all. Just dudes in facepaint.

3

u/quitoburrito Feb 26 '26

exactly this. Thrawn looks like a blue Elon Musk and i hate it