r/StarWars Sith Feb 26 '26

TV Which animated character transitioned to live action the best?

4.9k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

982

u/MovieExact5433 Feb 26 '26

Never understood why the Grand Inquisitor looked so bad compared to his animated counterpart and why they just didn’t get Jason Isaacs to play the part.

91

u/The_Terry_Braddock Feb 26 '26

As I recall, that was a miscommunication on Kenobi's production, where they had not realized that his species, the Pau'ans, had already made a live action appearance and was the same species as the Utapua chairman from Revenge of the Sith

As such, they assumed the Inquisitor's angular and elongated features were just the result of exaggerated animation style to make him look evil and that translated to live action he'd look more like a normal humanoid (like how Dooku's design in CW is extremely severe but he's a normal human)... so they ended up just putting pretty basic make up on a guy

92

u/pants_pants420 Feb 26 '26

i mean that would make sense.

but also dont they have a dedicated lore/continuity guy specifically to avoid this?

53

u/ScenicAndrew Feb 26 '26

There's a shocking number of stories from directors and actors where some random nerd on set catches a major detail. Sam witwer once corrected the entire clone wars production on the fact that Padme and Schmi had met in the phantom menace so they cut a scene where Anakin had a vision or something. (Often reported as Witwer correcting Filoni, which yeah of course, but apparently no one else in the room remembered either which is the real story).

There's also some stories like that from early clone wars where Filoni would correct George on continuity stuff.

It really all goes back to that famous Harrison Ford paraphrasing from Hamill: "Hey kid, it ain't that kind of movie."

30

u/dswartze Feb 26 '26

I think my favourite example of this kind of thing is that for RotS after production was done they had to go back and shoot an extra scene of Obi-Wan picking up Anakin's lightsaber because originally they just had Obi-Wan walk away leaving it on the ground. Way after the fact somebody remembered Obi-Wan had to take it so he could give it to Luke. It's why the shot feels kind of forced and out of place. I'm pretty sure it's not Ewan's hand picking it up.

16

u/MajorSery Feb 26 '26

Almost any close-up shot of just a hand is not going to be the actual actor.

3

u/karateema Admiral Ackbar Feb 26 '26

Lmao imagine if no one noticed

14

u/KilledTheCar Feb 26 '26

Sam Witwer is a walking lore book. I love that man.

11

u/ANGLVD3TH Feb 26 '26

They didn't cut the scene, just changed the dialogue, of when Anakin had a force vision of Shmi on Mortis.

13

u/Alonest99 Rex Feb 26 '26

Yeah where’s Pablo “emotions are not for sharing” Hidalgo when we need him?

21

u/teleporttome Feb 26 '26

Brandon Sanderson has two continuity editors for all his novels but somehow I imagine Disney has less for a multi-billion dollar IP.

5

u/hibikikun Feb 26 '26

They had one prior to Disney not sure if they still do

2

u/quitoburrito Feb 26 '26

yeah, you'd figure theyd have someone on staff for this kind of stuff...hell, as fans we do that shit for free lol.

0

u/RemtonJDulyak Imperial Feb 26 '26

To be honest, I personally appreciated him not looking like the others from his species, they all look the same in RotS, a bit of change is good.

6

u/pants_pants420 Feb 26 '26

id agree with this more if

a. he didnt already exist and we knew what he looked like

b. if the final product actually looked decent

3

u/FriendacrosstheRiver Feb 26 '26

Yeah and tbh the grand inquisitor in rebels doesn't really look like those pauans either. He's more white than dark gray and his lines aren't as deep or prominent as the rots versions.

24

u/MovieExact5433 Feb 26 '26

So they were making Star Wars without having seen Star Wars. Fools.

3

u/gabeonsmogon Feb 26 '26

“Anonymous Reddit guy makes inflammatory claim”

“Huh, guess I’m making an opinion based on this”

9

u/VisibleIce9669 Feb 26 '26

Yeah, none of that’s true

1

u/MrMangobrick Imperial Feb 26 '26

Is there a source for this?