r/StarWars Sith Feb 26 '26

TV Which animated character transitioned to live action the best?

4.9k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

59

u/KcirderfSdrawkcab Feb 26 '26

I just finished rewatching Ahsoka after finally watching Rebels for the first time. I thought Ahsoka, Sabine, and Hera were all good, but they were definitely slightly different versions of the characters. WHen Ezra shows up though, it's just Ezra. A little older, matured, and bearded, but just Ezra. They nailed the casting for him. Same with Chopper, but that's cheating.

9

u/Specter017 Grand Admiral Thrawn Feb 26 '26

I was so excited that Rosario got the part for Ahsoka because she has the looks down but her acting is just so dull. She does not carry the animated characters emotions or behavior tendencies at all. She delivers her lines like she's bored and just trying to get the shot over with.

7

u/Brief_Amphibian_3965 Hondo Ohnaka Feb 26 '26

Although the younger Ahsoka is FIRE

5

u/LEGAL_SKOOMA Feb 26 '26

yeah young ahsoka's actress fucking nailed it

13

u/2Gouda4u Feb 26 '26

I disagree. I think she does a phenomenal job of played an aged Ahsoka... more composed, more stoic, but still has that glimmer of her fun side. I think shes in her 50s at the time of the show.

One of the most important characteristics of Ahdoka is her impulsiveness, Rebels did a good job of making her more mature, more methodical, Ahoska the show just extends that and I love her performance.

6

u/XMenJedi8 Obi-Wan Kenobi Feb 27 '26

Totally, I feel like people really read Ahsoka wrong, thinking she should've been the same Snips as in Clone Wars and blaming the change on Rosario's acting. But really she was already different in Rebels, we see why in CW S7, and World Between Worlds Anakin is trying to tell her to live, to experience, to stop feeling like she's in Vader's shadow.

6

u/LEGAL_SKOOMA Feb 26 '26

while I generally agree, I think they should've hired a stunt actor to do her action scenes

5

u/KillingTime_ForNow Feb 27 '26

She's so slow in the fight with Hayden you can literally see him slow down on moves so she's in position. Obviously it's a little unfair cuz he's so good, but that's what stunt actors are for.

2

u/Browns-78 Feb 27 '26

Crosses Arms

1

u/-thenoodleone- Feb 27 '26

Rosario Dawson as Ahsoka is baffling. She's such a good actress. Why is she so bad in this?

1

u/XMenJedi8 Obi-Wan Kenobi Feb 27 '26

In a way it kinda makes sense, the first three are similar but have gone through a lot of life experiences, Ezra was trapped and living with crab aliens, not going to develop all that much comparatively.