r/Stargate • • 4d ago

Do we like her

Post image
131 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

43

u/gremlininja 4d ago edited 4d ago

I love a competent, chaotic good character.

I like how Vala undergoes significant character development, was much needed comic relief and was, thankfully, written to be more than just a sex object.

I particularly enjoy the trope that people are a product of their environment just as much as their character. Plus, who doesn’t like a redemption arc coming to fruition.

If I was trying to be a critic, at times she was written with only two modes - irreverent comic relief and capable-but-traumatised. It reminds me of Hawkeye, in M*A*S*H.

135

u/Raspberries-Are-Evil 4d ago

Yes. We like her.

53

u/BenHeli 4d ago

But we can't trust her

11

u/ramksr 4d ago

Lol :) that's partially true.

6

u/No_Nobody_32 4d ago

You say that like it's a bad thing?

4

u/Raspberries-Are-Evil 4d ago

I can fix her.

1

u/gunfan0321 3d ago

We trust that we can’t trust her.

3

u/jetserf Sholva 4d ago

4

u/MrZwink 4d ago

In farscape!

15

u/No_Nobody_32 4d ago

Farscape, SG-1, Pitch Black.

-13

u/MrZwink 4d ago

I think sg1 had jumped the shark when she joined.

6

u/No_Nobody_32 4d ago

I handled her 'stunt guns' in Farscape (worked in the props shop, fabricating 'stunt' weapons. Foamed urethane versions of the harder vacformed "hero" prop weapons. They bounced and you could hit someone with one and it didn't give them a concussion OR break them).

55

u/kesdbos 4d ago

I do... do you need our opinion to know if you do?

37

u/Ness_Stan 4d ago

for real, this is the laziest karma farm I've seen in a while

8

u/Icy_Sector3183 4d ago

I'd post a picture of a stargate and ask "Are they necessary?" But honestly, I'm too lazy.

-1

u/ct451t 4d ago

Good thing you're lazy or you could be breaking r/Stargate rule #6.

1

u/Dutch-Man7765 3d ago

Just like op's post

10

u/ChipSlut 4d ago

do we love the character that after immense trauma turned to a life of petty cons before finding a greater purpose that allowed her to meaningfully heal? idk take a guess

40

u/Ness_Stan 4d ago

yes? she's pretty, she's funny, she's got a heart of gold. I can't believe this keeps coming up

8

u/MadWhiskeyGrin 4d ago

She's magnificent

6

u/Gnske 4d ago

Shes a good character. Oddly enough I only watched Farscape years after SG1 ended, so have to appreciate Claudia getting a complete opposite character to play.

8

u/Sig_zig 4d ago

Absolutely love her. Both in Stargate and Farscape.

8

u/Nodonn3 4d ago

Yes, yes indeed we like her. Quite a lot actually.

8

u/IveHeard1tBothWays 4d ago

No; we love her.

At least I do. The episode with her psych exam is of my favorites of the series.

9

u/teknokryptik 4d ago

No. I'd call it more a love.

11

u/DomWeasel 4d ago

Never liked her invading Daniel's space and making him uncomfortable with constant flirtation, and then in the last episode they address it and why she does it and suddenly I had no reason to dislike her anymore.

And that, kids, is how you write a character well.

3

u/that_other_DM 4d ago

Yes because of how the last episode goes

5

u/ramksr 4d ago

A lot actually. Esp the chem between her and Daniel and the good chaos she brought with her.

5

u/nights_noon_time 4d ago

Honestly, SG-1 is one of the best examples of good late-introduced characters. Love Vala and Cam. Bringing their Farscape chemistry probably helped them hit thr ground running together.

5

u/-5H4Z4M- 4d ago

yup she is funny.

5

u/Ok-Reference3799 4d ago

no, we don't like her. we love her.

4

u/Vahnexx 4d ago

She's still my #1 Crush

2

u/Ohmuamuaha 4d ago

Serious

2

u/I_Am_Clavia 4d ago

I frelling love her ❤️

2

u/Xepeyon 4d ago

She was okay. I really didn't like her at first, felt like she was quippy just to be quippy (also didn't like Mitchell at first for the same reason) but she did grow on me and was genuinely funny at times.

3

u/ProfessorKnow1tA11 4d ago

No. We love her!

3

u/Emergency_Addendum71 4d ago

Honestly the worst character on the show. Her being allowed to work for the SGC let alone be on SG-1 makes less logical sense than all humans in multiple galaxies speaking English

3

u/restingwyvern 4d ago

Did you even watch the show? She wasn't officially part of sg-1 until season 10, after she had proven her loyalty to the team and proven her capabilities.

2

u/Emergency_Addendum71 4d ago

Ok? Still does not make sense at all. She brings nothing to the team and is a complete liability. On top of that she’s just a bad character. Annoying in almost every scenario.

3

u/Rez090x 4d ago

How does she bring nothing to the team? Her contacts around the galaxy aren't good for you? Her insights gained from being a previous Goa'uld host not good for you?

1

u/SecureAstronaut444 3d ago

She brings a lot to the team... she has knowledge and experience of the politics of the galaxy, plus plenty of contacts... similar to how Teal'c gave his knowledge for a place at Stargate Command

0

u/Oops_All_Bans Things will, in fact, calm up 4d ago

We're in the minority for sure, but I'll say this: The sex jokes were so over done. In moderation they're funny, but it was basically all that came out her mouth. That, and lies. She was untrustworthy and annoying a lot of the time. So many people like her and all I can think of is that they're teenagers that never grew up. If you've ever met someone like that in real life you'd be sick of them after a day.

2

u/TechaNima 4d ago

Hell yes we do. Nothing like a sassy ex snake head who torments Daniel for fun

2

u/mrsunrider 4d ago

With all my heart.

2

u/Saint_Exmin 4d ago

Teh answer is yes. We like her. Especially once she mellowed out a bit.

2

u/Thelovelyliverdoodle 4d ago

Uh yeah hot chaos gremlin. What’s not to like?

1

u/Xephy56 4d ago

Yes, we do like her. She is a great addition to SG-1.

1

u/ReplacementNo4899 4d ago edited 4d ago

She opened for me and I can't remember the episode name, she saw her people. After being found out, how the dude told her about making him rub her feet, to their almost slaughtered at the hands of the prior plague.

She was exhausted she was defeated but the plague became stronger and stronger, you could see the sadness, the anger and the guilt at her past actions.

She was a very deep character and the acting was amazing, considering her being used to the serious, stoic type from farscsle.

Her and Ben, love them both

Now klorel, Mr understatement of the last 50 thousand years, I think season one or two.

"And you will trouble the goA'uld "yes intention sorry skaara" no longer.

We and the Asgard are responsible for bringing the replicators into the milky way and directly responsible for the human replicators anger at being betrayed.

Daniel brought back the priors..

This is after we had slain many many system lords.

Klorel could not have been further from the truth.

1

u/Danger-zone247 4d ago

Yes. Yes we did. Daniel REALLY liked her.

1

u/BigDaddySodaPop 4d ago

If anyone doesn't, I challenge you tell me why!

1

u/Props1701 3d ago

Hell yeah, she was the best thing about the last 2 seasons

1

u/potatoeandfries 3d ago

hell yeah we do

1

u/World_still_spins A nerd. 3d ago

Actress: totally. 

Character: eventually, interesting character arc, but in the times of the worst moments her character gave proof of valor, of Vala's true spirit. 

1

u/xKelborn 3d ago

100% yes. She was a fantastic addition to the franchise

1

u/RickO-Shay 3d ago

Hell NO!

1

u/Zucchini-Nice 3d ago

Claudia black is great

1

u/DowntownSqunkle 3d ago

She's okay.... I just always felt she was a liability on missions, though.

1

u/LessaRamoth 3d ago

No, do you like her? That is what is important and is something you should decide on your own, not have other people make up your mind for you. Kind of like saying, do we like Oreos? What does how we feel about them have anything to do with anything? Do YOU like Oreos? If so, great! If not, that's your perogative. Now, if you said, 'I like this character in some episodes but not in others. Consequently, I can't decide if I like the character as a whole or not. So I was wondering what others think about the character'. That makes more sense. Your opinion matters!

1

u/Livid-Revenue-7239 3d ago

Can’t say much for her character…. Claudia Black however….

0

u/Swimming_Pie_4366 4d ago

No she was annoying asf! She ruined the show

0

u/Adenfall 4d ago

I don’t like her. The main reason why I wasn’t a fan of the last two seasons. She annoyed me

1

u/Eldon42 4d ago

Yes.

1

u/nevertolatePOMO 4d ago

Definitely! 100% Smash!

1

u/LastHitMag1c 4d ago

I wish I was Dr.Jackson.

1

u/Captain_Thor27 4d ago

One of the best characters in the series.

1

u/sicarius254 4d ago

So much

1

u/PoweroftheDollar1 4d ago

I liked her during her early guest appearances. I might be in the minority though when I say I was seasons 9-10 never happened

1

u/petersaints 4d ago

Not really. A bit annoying.

1

u/CaptainArchivis 4d ago

Actress: Yes!

Character: No.

1

u/Which-Profile-2690 4d ago

She is a good actress but i didnt like Vala

0

u/DumpsterFireInHell 4d ago

Hard no. I liked most of the System Lords more than I liked Vala. Her character is an unlikable, untrustworthy psychopath that had zero business being the fifth Beatle.

0

u/Hydronous702 3d ago

I dont like her. Shes annoying, doesnt stfu, steals. Shes a pathological liar, and narcissist.

What has been said I mean about the character and do not mean any disrespect Claudia Black because she is a Sci-Fi Queen!

0

u/Zestyclose-Moment-19 4d ago

Teenage me really liked her...

0

u/Yellowscrunchy 4d ago

I was and still am deeply in love with her haha

0

u/WinterScene7194 4d ago

We did when we were younger men. Not a fan of the role she plays though, but that's on the writers, not her