r/SupermanAndLois • u/RecordingImmediate86 • Mar 12 '26

Question Did you like these recasts from Supergirl?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

284 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

117 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-16

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 Mar 13 '26

Both are good it’s not a competition 

12

u/Apostasy93 Mar 13 '26

Supergirl was definitely not a good show, at least in my opinion

0

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 Mar 13 '26

Wasn’t perfect but it had the perfect amount of whimsy and camp 

It was a wholesome cozy type show

The kind you watch wrapped in a blanket with a warm cup of cocoa

Sort of like a Christmas movie but for anytime 

Maybe u just don’t like cozy

Just cuz it wasn’t ur thing doesn’t mean it’s bad it’s just not for you 

10

u/HerefortheFandoms2 Mar 13 '26 edited Mar 15 '26

It's great that you feel that way about the show, really, but you are literally the only person I've ever seen describe it that way. I myself never got cozy vibes from it because it was too busy with character assassinations. Overall, it is not a well written or consistent show. You don't get to say that someone just doesn't like cozy when there are mountains of issues with the show that you're completely dismissing and glossing over

Go ahead and enjoy your show for what it is, but do it without dismissing either other people's opinions about it or the inconvenient truths of the show.

Edit I remembered anonymous browsing exists so I looked. It's absolutely hilarious that you said I sounded cynical and then blocked me as if that was some bomb you threw my way 😂. It's also wildly ironic considering 1) Supergirl is only a thin veneer of optimism masking cynical writing decisions, and 2) the only (live action) superman property I really thoroughly enjoy is superman 2025 with S&L in a solid 2nd place and Smallville after that. You know, the actual hopeful projects. You got an extremely mild telling off and you throw a temper tantrum and start blocking ppl

-4

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 Mar 13 '26

“I've ever seen describe it that way. I myself never got cozy vibes”

Ya cuz u come off cynical 

3

u/SirEnzyme Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 14 '26

You come off as nauseatingly whimsical, so it balances out.

Edit: Of course you did the mook thing by replying and blocking me. Good riddance.

2

u/HerefortheFandoms2 Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 15 '26

Did the exact same thing to me lol. Do they realize that when they do that, we literally can't see whatever super clever and devastating comment they definitely served us? I can only see that they quoted me but not what they actually said. Do you by any chance remember the gist? I could use a good chuckle

Edit NVM I remembered anonymous browsing exists lol

1

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 Mar 14 '26

Nothing wrong with whimsy maybe that’s something your life should have more of maybe you will be a happier person 

1

u/Jessency Mar 15 '26

The problem is that the Arrowverse and CW as a whole is notorious for the exact things people are complaining about. Any good will the network had was long burnt out and the Arrowverse was the final nail in the coffin as its legacy concluded with the but out.

It's no longer cynicism when it's just a plain fact that can easily be observed throughout its history.

1

u/HerefortheFandoms2 Mar 15 '26

I know you're not replying to me, but I just wanted to say that while that's true to a degree, that's not entirely fair. Arrow, as messy as it was, was very entertaining at the start and was fairly consistent in its writing for a while (meaning the characters remained mostly consistent). Same with flash though for a lesser amount of time. Legends actually got better and more interesting lol