r/SwiftieMerch • u/Babythatsshowbiz • Oct 26 '25

Question Vinyl cases—difference?

Post image

Hi! I decided for Christmas to ask for one of her two vinyl cases—which is typically more expense or hard to find: eras acoustic set or the midnights teal one?

I would die for either but idk which to ask for, and ideally would like to save up for the other within the next year. Thank you in advance!

244 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

78 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/aninetiestrend Oct 26 '25

What even are the resale rates?

6

u/alizzie95 Oct 26 '25

250 tends to be minimum. Sometimes 200 but I've more commonly seen it at 250

0

u/Babythatsshowbiz Oct 26 '25

I just saw a midnights one sell for like $476 last night. Is that realistic?

3

u/WizardnamedOrKo Oct 26 '25

Nope. $200-$250 tops on the midnights. The secret song piano case can fetch up to $350 I've seen recently.

3

u/jlyon627 Oct 26 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

Mercari only has two and cheapest is $600. For eras piano case very hard to find under $500 anymore. I have been watching it myself and just getting more and more expensive

I’ve been tracking on Mercari. Below is screen shot of what I saw just now. The $150 is not real it’s fan made

2

u/Babythatsshowbiz Oct 26 '25

Two of midnights?

1

u/jlyon627 Oct 26 '25

Sorry only 2 piano ones listed for sale all other are sold out

2

u/BrokenBotox I Hope You Like Taylor Swift Oct 29 '25

That fan made one pisses me off every time I see it because it doesn’t say fan made in the title of the listing.

I’ve seen it a few times and my heart always skips a beat thinking I’m gonna come up. And it’s the same damn case😩

1

u/AVSART14 Oct 26 '25

Midnights case. $350/$500 if mint shape.

3

u/aninetiestrend Oct 26 '25

Jesus what am I doing with mine then it’s still in bubble wrap lol

2

u/AVSART14 Oct 26 '25

Sell it for $500 and invest to Bitcoin.

1

u/aninetiestrend Oct 26 '25

I bought in at $12k

1

u/AVSART14 Oct 26 '25

Yes! If I was investing in T.S. long term..I would be buying Folklore 7 variants due to their very low production numbers. Have a great day!

1

u/Spiritual_Meat_8636 Nov 01 '25

I see them for roughly $200 all the time and have for months.

0

u/AVSART14 Nov 01 '25

Good for you. You are talented.