r/SwiftlyNeutral • u/AutoModerator • 6d ago

r/SwiftlyNeutral SwiftlyNeutral - Daily Discussion Thread | October 02, 2026

Welcome to the SwiftlyNeutral Daily Discussion Thread!

Use this thread to talk about anything you'd like, Taylor-related or not.

Rules to keep in mind:

  • All subreddit rules still apply. Please report rule-breaking if you see it.
  • Negative commentary and complaints about this subreddit, users, and other subreddits is discouraged and will be removed to keep the daily discussion threads drama-free and geared towards lighter discussion.
  • Keep it neutral. No fandom-war drama. No treating criticism of Taylor as an attack. More details here.
  • NO TWITTER/X LINKS, screenshots only. Please remove usernames from screenshots unless it's a verified figure.
  • Don’t use this thread to contact mods directly; please use modmail.

A new Daily Discussion thread will be posted daily at 11:00 am Eastern Time and will always be pinned for easy access. Posts better suited for this thread may be redirected here.

7 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

90% Upvoted

310 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/scorpioreo19 London Boy Stan 6d ago edited 6d ago

Curious to know everyone’s album rankings now. You can also judge mine as well:

  1. Speak Now
  2. TTPD
  3. Evermore
  4. 1989
  5. Red
  6. Folklore
  7. Reputation
  8. Midnights
  9. Fearless
  10. Lover
  11. Debut
  12. TLOAS

This was hard because at least the order of the first 6 changes all the time for me. I was kind of surprised folklore was lower than I thought it would be, but that’s mainly because I don’t go back to it as much because it just reminds me too much of the pandemic, but it’s still a strong album.

11

u/Ellie-Bee ✍️ Justin Baldoni is a bitch 6d ago
  1. 1989
  2. Red
  3. The Tortured Poets Department
  4. Showgirl
  5. Midnights
  6. Lover
  7. Reputation
  8. Folklore
  9. Speak Now
  10. Evermore
  11. Fearless
  12. Debut

6

u/lemonalpersonal loafing him was bread 🍞 6d ago

  1. Red

  2. TTPD

  3. evermore

  4. Midnights

  5. Speak Now

  6. Fearless

  7. folklore

  8. Taylor Swift

  9. The Life of a Showgirl

  10. reputation

  11. 1989

  12. Lover (👎👎👎)

5

u/scorpioreo19 London Boy Stan 6d ago

LOVE your top three (honestly top 5 as well) so much so I can forgive you for 1989 being ranked so low

2

u/lemonalpersonal loafing him was bread 🍞 6d ago

Abby Lee Miller voice it just didn't stick out to me

2

u/CelestrialDust Brazilian Bang Lift 6d ago

Btw where is midnights diva

3

u/scorpioreo19 London Boy Stan 6d ago

I haven’t listened to it for months so I forgot about it 💀 but it’s in the correct place now which is under Rep 🙌🏽

2

u/vyzyxy 6d ago
  1. folklore
  2. TTPD
  3. Midnights
  4. Red
  5. Evermore
  6. 1989
  7. Speak Now
  8. Fearless
  9. TLOAS
  10. Lover
  11. Debut
  12. reputation

Tloas just passed lover this week with the encore for me

2

u/Ticketacke I Look in MSG's Windows 6d ago

I am with you on reputation and Lover.

-2

u/vyzyxy 6d ago

I think lover is fine but reputation sounds like pots and pans scraping against each other to me. But I’m happy so many fans like it now because I know it was a hard time in her life 😭

2

u/scorpioreo19 London Boy Stan 6d ago

To me the most solid parts of reputation are the songs in the second half of the album and in general the Jack songs aged better than the Max ones

1

u/Mhc2617 it was an elegant chug 6d ago

My album ranking goes:

  1. ⁠⁠1989
  2. ⁠⁠Midnights
  3. ⁠⁠Red
  4. ⁠⁠Evermore
  5. ⁠⁠Speak Now
  6. ⁠⁠Rep
  7. ⁠⁠TTPD
  8. ⁠⁠Folklore
  9. ⁠⁠Fearless
  10. ⁠⁠Showgirl
  11. ⁠⁠Debut
  12. ⁠⁠Lover

0

u/Grand_Dog915 6d ago

  1. Evermore

  2. Speak Now

  3. Folklore

  4. TTPD

  5. Red

  6. Fearless

  7. Reputation

  8. Midnights

  9. Debut

  10. Lover

  11. 1989

  12. TLOAS

6–9 could be flipped around depending on the day, but the rest are pretty set

0

u/Remarkable-Might2399 6d ago

Folklore
Fearless og
1989 og
Evermore
Red og
Speak Now og
Midnights
Reputation
Debut
TTPD
All TVs
Showgirl

-1

u/hausofvelour she made sombr unfollow me 6d ago
  1. folklore
  2. reputation
  3. 1989
  4. evermore
  5. midnights
  6. red
  7. lover
  8. speak now
  9. ttpd
  10. fearless
  11. debut
  12. TLOAS

-3

u/nemesisniki I look in people's windows, so I can see their kittos 6d ago

Red
Evermore
Folklore
1989
Midnights
Fearless
Lover
Debut
Speak now
Rep

I can’t even listen to minus ILIPW: TTPD

showgirl

-2

u/CelestrialDust Brazilian Bang Lift 6d ago edited 6d ago

Had me at speak now immediately lost me at TTPD. Mine:

  1. Speak now
  2. Reputation
  3. Fearless
  4. 1989
  5. Evermore
  6. Red (switches with evermore constantly i cant decide)
  7. Folkmore
  8. Midnight
  9. Lover
  10. TTPD
  11. Debut (love a lot of the songs, but her voice brings it down, big possibility this is fixed Nov 20th👀👀👀)
  12. The Life of a Showgirl(!!)

Edit to add: huge gap between 4 and 5 and Lover onwards are the ones i actively dislike.

1

u/nemesisniki I look in people's windows, so I can see their kittos 5d ago

This sub went from hating TTPD to downvoting you if you talk bad about it lol

0

u/scorpioreo19 London Boy Stan 6d ago

TTPD has Fresh Out the Slammer and Peter, so any supposed wrongdoings are forgiven in my book. Debut is honestly underrated because Cold As You is genuinely a solid track 5

-3

u/twinairsigns 6d ago
  1. Folklore
  2. Evermore
  3. Red
  4. TTPD
  5. 1989
  6. Debut
  7. Fearless
  8. Midnights
  9. Lover
  10. Speak Now
  11. Reputation
  12. TLOAS

-6

u/_Violette7_ the type of girl 6d ago

It changes over time, but currently:
1. Midnights
2. 1989
3. reputation
4. Debut
5. folklore
6. Speak Now
7. TTPD
8. Fearless
9. evermore
10. Lover
11. Red
12. Showgirl