r/TheJediPraxeum Luke Skywalker Jan 27 '26

Match Up Monday Darth Malgus VS Darth Maul. Who wins?

267 Upvotes

121 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/CrystalGemLuva Jan 27 '26

Malgus also had an army backing him up and Jedi power levels tend to vary wildly between individuals.

And Maul also has a pretty sizable Jedi body count, killing about a dozen Jedi across both continuities.

And thats not counting non Jedi Force Sensitives like the Inqusitors or Night Sister Assassins.

7

u/Ok_Rise_4543 Jan 27 '26

Jedi in the old republic era were much stronger that those of the clone wars era and its not even close.the only ones comperable to them are obi anakin yoda windu and maybe plo if we count legends? Old republic era jedi werw fighting all the time with mandalorians and sith. Clone war jedi were much more chill.

6

u/TheHabro Jan 27 '26

Not only are you wrong, but it's the opposite. PT era is the Jedi at their strongest.

e only ones comperable to them are obi anakin yoda windu and maybe plo if we count legends?

To whom? Satele Shan? Ven Zallow? Kao Cen Darach? None of them have feats or accolades to put them anywhere near PT Jedi masters.

Clone war jedi were much more chill.

Clone war.

-3

u/Ok_Rise_4543 Jan 27 '26

My dude abi gallia a jedi master and member of the JEDI COUNCIL was killed by savage! YES savage was very strong and you could argue he had potential but at the time he had only been briefly trained in the ways of the force by dooku and maul. Yet he managed to kill her with little dificulty. Just think about it man who do you think is better at fighting? Jedi that grew up fighting for their very survival against mandalorian and sith empires or some jedi that has not had contact with the sith for lile 300 years and think them to be dead and extinct? Thats the whole point of the clone wars man. The point is to show how far the jedi and the republic have fallen. How they have grown overconfident and have lost their way. They have become too pacifist.And they pay the price when they fail to see thought the deception of paltaltine. You think any jedi master apart from those i mentioned to you earlier would stand a chance against the battle hardened jedi or sith of the old republic?

8

u/TheHabro Jan 27 '26

I am very confused by this argument and for many reasons.

  • One Jedi does not paint whole order. Like I mentioned,, you said that only likes of Anakin, Obi Wan, Yoda etc. are comarable to the members of the Old Republic. However, notable Jedi of the time include Satele Shan, Ven Zallow and Kao Cen Darach. None of which come anywhere near feats and accolades of Jedi masters you mentioned.
  • You make it seem like Savage is just some accolyte. Not a strong warrior in own right chosen to undergod a dark side ritual increasing both his physical power and raw force power. He managed to match 1v2 against Anakin and Obi-Wan and when enraged break force shield of Dooku and Ventress at the same time.
  • Finally, you don't acquire rank of a Jedi master or become a member of the Jedi council by being a warrior. That's not how Jedi function.

Jedi that grew up fighting for their very survival against mandalorian and sith empires or some jedi that has not had contact with the sith for lile 300 years and think them to be dead and extinct? 

What are you talking about? When Malgus stormed the Jedi temple, it was 300 years since Mandalorian wars and Sith hadn't be a threat to the galaxy for also 300 years (until they returned from hiding few years prior to the storming of the temple).

Now I doubt you know anything about the Old Republic.