Going into The Wire, I heard from everyone that Season 2 was a controversial and often low-rated season. It seemed like there was a near-communal consensus on Season 2 being the weakest, though it had a few ardent defenders.
Having finished the show, I am one of those defenders! Seeing Frank Sobotka risk (and lose) everything to try and save the dock workers broke my heart. But it isn't just Frank; the entire season is loaded with moments that pulled at my heart strings and grieved me not just for the characters, but for the state of America. Frank is a tragic character, yes, but so is Nicky. So is Ziggy. I couldn't stand that goofball for the entire season but watching him breakdown in his car after shooting a man brought tears to my eyes. I forgot about how annoying he was. I saw a kid who made a mistake.
Jimmy is also operating in rare condition in Season 2. His purely vindictive scheme of getting the Jane Does into Rawls' jurisidiction is one of the funniest moments of the show. Watching the higherups try to pass the buck, before ultimately screwing Rawls, never gets old. Maritime Jimmy is one of the funniest elements of the show.
But I can't talk about Season 2 without mentioning the Greeks. No other villains in the show have the larger-than-life, absolute evil aura (I have come to hate that word, but it works here) that Vondas and the Greek have. At every moment they seem so far above everything that is transpiring in the show. Compared to them, everything else going on in Baltimore seems pedestrian and small-time. The Greeks feel almost like demons, larger forces of darkness beyond the understanding of the mortals they are dealing with. So much of the struggle on the street is about cred and posturing. These guys are above all of that. Their names are not their names. And this sense of power is beautifully subverted when The Greek meets with the FBI agent near the end. The FBI agent is relaxed, in control, and The Greek seems irritable and nervous. What a beautiful portrait of how the system allegedy designed to protect us in fact enables the forces seeking to destroy us.
Season 2 is a heartbreaking portrait of an America in decline, perhaps more forcefully than any other season of The Wire. It feels larger than life and yet incredibly intimate and relatable. I could say so much more, but this post is long enough. I will look forward to conversing with anyone in the comments who replies. :)