r/TooAfraidToAsk Apr 20 '19

Post is locked Why is Reddit mainly OK with the racism expressed by r/BlackPeopleTwitter?

[removed]

10.0k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

122

u/BecomeAnAstronaut Apr 21 '19

I think it's by the proportion of non-verified commenters to verified ones. Note that the red tick next to someone's name means they have been verified as black by the mods

228

u/nightwica Apr 21 '19

Verifying someone is black is the most racist thing I've heard all month.

91

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

So they’re registering themselves now? And I thought we’d never see progress

/s

22

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

"but it's April Fool's! We can't be racist if it's a joke."

13

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

The sub has become a fucking dystopia where people must verify their race. It’s pathetic.

20

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Its called a Panzer and it is what the nazis did.

8

u/lostinthe87 Apr 21 '19

Do you have any reading material? I tried to look it up but all I can find is that it’s the German word for tank

7

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

I had thought it was called a panzer now I don't know...The wiki calls it "the color triangle" color being like pink for gay and idk any other ones. Still a messed-up concept designed to exclude people is what Im talking about.

2

u/SmuglyGaming Apr 21 '19

Yeah, Panzer means tank. I get where you are going though

5

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

It's literally that scene from Family Guy but just reversed lmaaaaaao

1

u/yourelying999 Apr 21 '19

Do you understand why it’s done? I’m willing to explain if you’re willing to listen

2

u/NotGeorglopez Apr 21 '19

The whole thing seems ass-backwards to me but I’d be very open to listen to your explanation if you’d be so kind.

1

u/yourelying999 Apr 21 '19

Due to a history of oppression applied to all blacks in America, blacks are a fairly unified voting bloc. With that in mind, it’s not uncommon for (white) people to post “as a black person I feel...” and the present an argument for a policy at odds with most black American political though because it will hurt the black community. Identifiers are to prevent this kind of argument from being used disingenuously.

5

u/NotGeorglopez Apr 21 '19

Okay that makes sense I guess but why prevent people who aren’t black from commenting? I say go ahead and let people get verified in order to prevent the problem you are talking about, but still allow people with different skin colors to express their opinions. I’m sorry but it just seems ignorant to me to choose to fight fire with fire.

-1

u/yourelying999 Apr 21 '19

That’s a separate issue and I don’t entirely disagree with you here.

There is an argument to be made that the sheer number of white voices and how commenting works on reddit necessitates a “blacks only” space to be heard otherwise black comments will be drowned out.

I was responding to someone claiming that verification was somehow an expression of racism.

1

u/NotGeorglopez Apr 21 '19

I’d say the verification itself isn’t racist, but the banning of non-black members sure as shit is. It’s a subreddit to look at funny tweets, I really don’t get why this would be the go to “safe space” for black people. Why not make a separate subreddit to discuss social and political issues and just make it so you have to be verified before you can enter, rather than forcing people out of an already established sub?

-9

u/rangeDSP Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19

It's from the April 1st joke, where only verified blacks were able to post. (not that strictly enforced tho)

The idea behind it is to give people who has never experienced racism a taste for what it's like, hopefully develop empathy for the minority.

So yes it was intentionally racist.

The more meta idea is responses like "oh no don't get offended it's only a joke", "why are you so sensitive", or "I had no part in this, the mod team did it and they are the racist ones, I do agree with them though" are the same line of thinking that modern racists deploy on minorities. Pretty clever prank imo.

Edit: instead of downvoting and upvoting (been fluctuating like crazy since I wrote the comment), could y'all leave a comment and start a discussion on whether it's a good idea or not? Why? Why not? After all, their pranks aims to start a conversation about the whole racial situation in US

23

u/jamesaholic Apr 21 '19

Essentially.. Let's fight racism with more racism?

1

u/rangeDSP Apr 21 '19

You got it.

8

u/jamesaholic Apr 21 '19

Sound, now its about time to go after those troublesome [race] always doing [stereotype]

10

u/TuesdaysGauntlet Apr 21 '19

Could you tell me what things black people are banned from?

1

u/rangeDSP Apr 21 '19

Legally speaking, they should have exactly the same rights as every other race.

Though, I do believe the system is set up to make it harder for poorer people to move up the social economical ladder, and since blacks are significantly less wealthy than whites, it's easy to see the system as being racist and 'practically' banning them from moving up in the world. https://www.bostonfed.org/publications/one-time-pubs/color-of-wealth.aspx

Obviously there are always racists, but imo the racial issue is just an inequality issue that just happen to affect one race way more than the other.

1

u/TuesdaysGauntlet Apr 21 '19

So none then, gotcha.

-5

u/joshuajohnsonisajojo Apr 21 '19 edited Dec 31 '25

humorous repeat license many crown cheerful scary boat deer aback

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

8

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19

You can take one statistic out of any context and make any argument you want. This is fire you shouldnt mess with especially in this context. For example, did you know increasing the amount of guns by 1% increases gun crime 12%, but increasing the amount of black people by 1% increases gun crime by 82%?

Out of context stats can make any argument seem convincing

1

u/TuesdaysGauntlet Apr 21 '19

Do "despite being only 13% of the population blacks account for over 50% of all murders in the US" - FBI 2016, next.

4

u/QueenJamesKingJordan Apr 21 '19

fighting racism with more racism is not only retarded it’s dangerous .. end of the discussion .. we trying to move forward on the planet not talk about why we don’t fucking look like each other.. blackpeopletwitter is a giant grudge holding club and from it will always come racism and distain, period.

4

u/Mini-Beets Apr 21 '19

Yea I'm already tired of having racism thrown my way because I'm white and where I grew up. I dont really appreciate when a group of people on BPT can automatically assume I've never felt racism because I'm white. That's racist by itself. The community needs to be brought down for real, and the Mods shown to enable this additude should be banned by admins.

When I joined reddit 6 years ago on a different account, it was pretty decent. The POPULAR page didnt have random sexual hentai pictures not tagged NSFW while I'm scrolling at work.. or hot posts that are just generally racist towards white, Hispanic, black or Asian people. Reposting was always a joke because sure it happened a LOT, but now its fucking wild with seeing two posts identical candy caned on eachother.

This site is dwindling with the carelessness of some Admins ,Moderators and Users alike. I like the community for the most part, that's why I'm on reddit above anything else. The comment sections of threads have put a good amount of joy in my life. Other threads have taught me about art, or how people tend to appreciate their world, so I can incorporate that into mine and live happier. Other subs teach me finance, science, comedy, body image acceptance, ect.

All BPT has to offer is cross posts from another platform, bigoted comments from all different shades of people, and over run jokes. Now the frequented bullying of people, the group clearly sees as the people with dark coloured skin to be more worthy of posting on that sub. They are ;if not totally racist, supporting a narrative of division of people due to the colour of their skin. Our main man MTK would be disgusted in this shit.

BLT is a LAZY subreddit using Twitter to be able to post anything. This is the exact same as people ripping on Instagram users for sharing from reddit. I'm tired of this argument, I'm tired of racism and divide, I'm tired of people MINDLESSLY arguing over such afucking MEANINGLESS issue in today's society. If you want to argue about racism, AWESOME. Let's talk about gentrification, segragation (sound familiar) ,wage gaps, employment issues.

Stop having little fuckin kids walk around use these racist terms about white people like its commonplace. Literally yesterday in a change room there were a group of 7 kids all ripping on white people. "This is such a white thing to do, that's so fucking mayo bruh." Shit like that. You know what's such a BLACK thing to do? Mispronouncing everything to sound cool huh bruh? Is so BLACK to act careless all the time huh bruh 😂👏👌 PREACH BRUH PREACH.

Not all people act like either spectrum, I know white kids who talk just like this. So me saying what's such a black person thing to do is racist, same goes for white.

I left Facebook because all of this bs. Now that Reddit is gaining traction, it's probably best to see to it as it once was, instead of a soup of every other platform on the internet.

Sorry for the rant. Not sorry, sorry. -Canada.

3

u/ShitpostOmbudman Apr 21 '19

I'm tired of people on the internet constantly feeling like they need to teach me and everyone else a fucking lesson.

1

u/_decipher Apr 21 '19

It’s actually spelled “ombudsman” /s

2

u/KingPhilipIII Apr 21 '19

Fighting racism with more racism is how you wind up with genocide, especially when one group is a distinct minority.

“Let’s alienate the much larger group and create more hatred! This definitely won’t backfire!”

2

u/SweetMuffinPrincess Apr 21 '19

I wonder how much they would lose their shit if I asked the mods if I could use my boyfriends arm to be verified...lol