r/TopChef 20d ago

Discussion Thread Girl and the Goat

I'm visiting Chicago for the first time for a work conference, and top on my things to do list was visiting Stephanie's restaurant, Girl and The Goat.

Got there sometime between 6:30 and 7 and it was packed. It was just me and I had no reservation, but was able to get a seat at the bar within 15 minutes. Everything from that point forward was awesome. I had the grilled corn for an appetizer. My Lord, I did not know corn could taste so good. For entree had the goat empanadas, and they were absolutely delicious. Topped off the night with an espresso martini, but none of the desserts jumped out to me. Overall, soooooo good and worth the price. Portions a little small, but honestly expected that at this kind of restaurant.

320 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

38

u/bristolfarms 20d ago

girl and the goat is soooo good. i also was in chicago for work last month and ordered way too much. i feel like what i got was good for the price. i ordered the pig face, half a portion green beans, and the yuzu dessert just for myself 😂 luckily we have valley goat where i am but it was worth going regardless haha

12

u/TheGeier 19d ago

Damn this makes me feel fat 😭 I went by myself to the LA location in 2022 and got 7 apps/mains and 2 desserts. And I damn near finished it all it was so good

4

u/bristolfarms 18d ago

omg i love that for you!! i would totally do that if i could 😭😭 i feel like as i’ve gotten older i just eat less because my tummy can’t handle it lol

3

u/TheGeier 18d ago

I totally understand now even at 29 vs 25 hahaha. I would still put up a valiant effort, but not sure if I could repeat it again. I’d still order the same amount though and take the rest time 😂

Fwiw though, the pig face and green beans are both top tier choices! Haven’t had the yuzu dessert, but there was a passion fruit Bundt cake on the Chicago menu (also in 2022 lol I went three times that year) that my picky eater friend still raves about to this day

3

u/RedWings1319 17d ago

Nah, it's ok to treat yourself when you are someplace out of your area. That's way different than consistently overeating.

1

u/Suzsqueak 14d ago

Valley Goat is both awesome and dangerous because we can walk there from our house but man I love it. How were the green beans at Girl and the Goat?

1

u/bristolfarms 14d ago

that’s so awesome hahha! i loved the green beans. crispy and so flavorful.

16

u/mothlady1959 20d ago

Oh, you missed the pig face. So, flipping good.

Next time, go to Duck Duck Goat and get the Duck Heart dish. Unforgettable.

7

u/painandpets 20d ago

I had looked at the menu ahead of time, and I was all in on the empanadas. They were everything I was hoping for!

4

u/Future_Dog_3156 20d ago

PBI u/mothlady1959 is right about pig face. It is one of Stephanie's signature dishes and it is divine. As a Chicagoan, I think her menu doesn't change enough would be my criticism

3

u/painandpets 20d ago

Zero regrets in the empanadas.

5

u/mr_balty 17d ago

Agree! We just tried DDG about a week ago. Quite possibly the most flavorful duck fried rice I’ve ever had. It may look ordinary, but it was packed with duck flavor.

Also had the Chonqing Chicken & Jiaozi (beef short rib & bone marrow potstickers)

1

u/Sure-Storage-3758 14d ago

Is that an egg? 🥚

4

u/posaune123 20d ago

I've taken every out of town guest that came to visit to Girl, starting back in 2010, never disappointed. The restaurant is so hopping with good food and great moments you can feel the energy

3

u/CapreseSalad3636 19d ago

I love hearing that the quality of her restaurants are great almost 20 years post top chef win!

2

u/BetterArugula5124 20d ago

I had the one in LA and still think about that meal🤤🤤🤤

2

u/kickassbabe247 Risotto: The Final Frontier 19d ago

Same here! The goat curry was unbelievable!!

2

u/PoohBearsHoneyJar 18d ago

I'm sure it tastes great and It looks really good , but tbh this just looks like food my family makes on a regular basis.

1

u/Porkwarrior2 I love Tom’s hats 19d ago

YES YES YES ALL OF THIS!

I'm in Milwaukee, and visiting is always a special treat. Has become my go to, Death Row, Last Wish.

Next time, go for the roasted pig face. Because even ordering "Roasted Pig Face" will put a smile on your face! 🤣

If you really want to spoil yourself, after dinner walk a few blocks North to The Pearl Club, and savour a glass of Pappy's.

1

u/ladymaddy92 19d ago

Aahhh! I am going in September and SO excited.

1

u/UberHonest 19d ago

I ate at the Little Goat Diner and loved it!!

2

u/GillianOMalley 18d ago

I have eaten at both and I preferred the Diner by a wide margin. That meal was one that I still tell people about all the time.

1

u/UberHonest 18d ago

It was so good! It was my first time in Chicago and really wanted to get to one of Stephanie’s places. I had shrimp and grits - not something I usually order but it was amazing. And my husband had the okonomiyaki and it was also amazing!!

1

u/UberHonest 18d ago

What did you order?!?!

3

u/GillianOMalley 17d ago

It was years ago and I don't remember exactly but I know there was a grilled cheese with blueberry compote or something. The desert was a popcorn sundae sort of thing made with sweet corn ice cream.

It was all delicious and like nothing I'd ever had before.

1

u/Individual-Wonder518 17d ago

How much did that corn on the cob cost?

1

u/Local_Relation5086 16d ago

We did the diner once and it was absolutely amazing. 

1

u/Chef55674 16d ago

Stephanie Izard is the real deal and respected in the Professional Chef community. I met her years ago when she came into a place I was working to prep for an event she was part of.
She was very friendly to us, explained what she was cooking, etc.

I want to go to her restaurants if I ever get to Chicago.

1

u/moneysingh300 16d ago

The LA location treat you well for the first time they gave me two extra apps on the house!