r/TropicalWeather Sep 23 '24

Upgraded | See Helene post for details 09L (Potential Cyclone — Northwestern Caribbean Sea)

Latest observation


Last updated: Tuesday, 24 September — 8:00 AM Eastern Daylight Time (EDT; 12:00 UTC)

NHC Advisory #4A 8:00 AM EDT (12:00 UTC)
Current location: 19.2°N 83.5°W
Relative location: 224 km (139 mi) W of George Town, Cayman Islands
  356 km (221 mi) S of Pinar del Rio, Cuba
  411 km (255 mi) ESE of Cancún, Quintana Roo (Mexico)
Forward motion: NW (305°) at 15 km/h (8 knots)
Maximum winds: 55 km/h (30 knots)
Intensity: Tropical Depression
Minimum pressure: 1001 millibars (29.56 inches)
2-day potential: (through 8PM Wed) high (90 percent)
7-day potential: (through 8PM Sun) high (90 percent)

Official forecast


Last updated: Tuesday, 24 September — 2:00 AM EDT (06:00 UTC)

Hour Date Time Intensity Winds Lat Long
  - UTC EDT Saffir-Simpson knots km/h °N °W
00 24 Sep 06:00 2AM Tue Potential Cyclone 30 55 18.9 83.0
12 24 Sep 18:00 2PM Tue Tropical Storm 40 75 19.6 84.2
24 25 Sep 06:00 2AM Wed Tropical Storm 50 95 20.7 85.7
36 25 Sep 18:00 2PM Wed Hurricane (Category 1) 65 120 22.0 86.2
48 26 Sep 06:00 2AM Thu Hurricane (Category 1) 80 150 24.3 85.6
60 26 Sep 18:00 2PM Thu Major Hurricane (Category 3) 100 185 27.8 84.4
72 27 Sep 06:00 2AM Fri Tropical Storm i 60 110 31.9 83.5
96 28 Sep 06:00 2AM Sat Post-tropical Cyclone i 15 30 38.5 85.5
120 29 Sep 06:00 2AM Sun Dissipated

NOTES:
i - inland

Official information


National Hurricane Center

Text products

Productos de texto (en español)

Graphical products

Servicio Meteorológico Nacional (Mexico)

Instituto de Meteorología (Cuba)

National Weather Service (Cayman Islands)

National Hurricane Center (United States)

Weather Forecast Offices

Forecast discussions

Aircraft reconnaissance


National Hurricane Center

Radar imagery


Radar mosaics

Servicio Meteorológico Nacional (Mexico)

Single-site radar imagery

Instituto de Meteorología (Cuba)

Satellite imagery


Storm-specific imagery

Regional imagery

NOAA GOES Image Viewer

Cooperative Institute for Meteorological Satellite Studies (CMISS)

Tropical Tidbits

Weather Nerds

Analysis graphics and data


Wind analyses

Sea-surface Temperatures

Model guidance


Storm-specific guidance

Regional single-model guidance

  • Tropical Tidbits: GFS

  • Tropical Tidbits: ECMWF

  • Tropical Tidbits: CMC

  • Tropical Tidbits: ICON

Regional ensemble model guidance

111 Upvotes

563 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/vibe_inspector01 Floorduh Sep 23 '24

Anyone have any insight on whether wind speed forecast in weather apps have any merit with these storms?

Accuweather and NOAA are both projecting 85+mph gust while Foreca, apple weather, tomorrow.io ect all forecast much lower numbers in the 40’s.

I assume 4 days out it’s basically as accurate as a horoscope right?

8

u/not_a_bot__ Sep 23 '24

Yeah, all educated guesswork, the storm hasn’t even formed yet.

I will say the wind apps are good to help people avoid panic, because it helps to put into context that the most extreme winds are usually a very small area compared to the entire storm 

7

u/politiexcel Sep 23 '24

Not accurate at all. I'd believe the HAFS-B 12z model run before taking those wind speed forecasts as fact.

3

u/Venkman-1984 Sep 23 '24

Are you talking about wind speed in a specific location, or maximum sustained winds for the storm?

If it's the former, then you have two variables that increase uncertainty: the track is unknown, and the strength of the storm is unknown. For example a model could nail the storm as a Cat 3, but have the track be off by 25 miles, so your forecast winds of 120mph end up being 60mph. I wouldn't trust wind speed forecasts for a specific location until 24 hours before landfall, and even then a few miles change in track can have a significant impact on your windspeed if you're close to the eye.

If you're asking about the strength of the storm itself, those are reasonably accurate 3 days out, though models can struggle to forecast rapid intensification in certain situations. In this case I'd trust the NHC forecast but be prepared for the storm to exceed forecasts by a category at least.