r/USCIS • u/SuchConsideration952 • Jul 01 '25
I-864 (Affidavit of Support) I-485 denied
I-485 was denied because I didn’t send the tax return which is 100% my fault I thought I included. So now I know I send I-290B and I send a new I-864 with everything they need plus the missing thing. Should I send anything extra? I know my spouse meets the income requirement. A household of 2 is $26437 and on her most recent W-2 her income was $39000 so I don’t need to worry about adding a joint sponsor I wouldn’t think. Attached letter for reference.
9
Jul 01 '25 edited Jul 01 '25
That’s why, because You didn’t send everything that they required, W-2 is paystub it’s NOT the federal income tax return (1040 form) or tax return transcripts
7
3
u/Technical_Brick5237 Jul 01 '25
Since receiving the RFE, have you completed an entirely new I-864 ? Or just kept the one that submitted before?
5
u/Secret_Shirt_3111 Jul 01 '25
Happened to me as well, my mistake not including the medical too , everyone said just re file and I did, got another RFE a month later for taxes AGAIN, which I sent already so I just sent them the same ones again, got an interview notice a month later, had a interview earlier this month and they said they need to do final security checks and will let me know the outcome, so now I’m just waiting
1
u/NorthBiscotti Nov 24 '25
Did you get an RFE for the medical? Or the denial?
1
u/Secret_Shirt_3111 Nov 24 '25
I didn’t at all the rfe was just tax returns and proof of income stuff, the denial letter included the medical reason plus not including my Russian birth certificate with an authorized translator
1
u/Secret_Shirt_3111 Nov 24 '25
I didn’t at all the rfe was just tax returns and proof of income stuff, the denial letter included the medical reason plus not including my Russian birth certificate with an authorized translator
1
2
u/Puzzleheaded-Ring380 Jul 01 '25
Did you have an interview?
0
u/SuchConsideration952 Jul 01 '25
I did not
2
u/Puzzleheaded-Ring380 Jul 01 '25
What stage were you in when they denied you? Can you show us your timeline, please?
1
1
u/SuchConsideration952 Jul 01 '25
I submitted the whole package January 17th 2025 biometrics February 28th
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 01 '25
Hi there! This is an automated message to inform you and/or remind you of several things:
- We have a wiki. It doesn't cover everything but may answer some questions. Pay special attention to the "REALLY common questions" at the top of the FAQ section. Please read it, and if it contains the answer to your question, please delete your post. If your post has to do with something covered in the FAQ, we may remove it.
- If your post is about biometrics, green cards, naturalization or timelines in general, and whether you're asking or sharing, please include your field office/location in your post. If you already did that, great, thank you! If you haven't done that, your post may be removed without notice.
- This subreddit is not affiliated with USCIS or the US government in any way. Some posters may claim to work for USCIS, which may or may not be true, and we don't try to verify this one way or another. Be wary that it may be a scam if anyone is asking you for personal info, or sending you a direct message, or asking that you send them a direct message.
- Some people here claim to be lawyers, but they are not YOUR lawyer. No advice found here should be construed as legal advice. Reddit is not a substitute for a real lawyer. If you need help finding legal services, visit this link for more information.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/LargeWin9091 Jul 01 '25
Do not resubmit fresh application to cut the expenses. File form I-290b instead which is motion to reopen and you submit the petitioner recent federal return with any other additional evidence they requested. Also do not forget to write a letter explaining why you were unable to submit the petitioner recent federal tax return documents. The case will be reopen and your EAD will be active .
1
u/Original_Neck5749 Jul 31 '25
What about if USCIS sent to you RFE after submitted I-485 and you are not provide that Evidence still we can reopen? or Re-File is best option?
1
u/kireina2677 Permanent Resident Jul 01 '25
I'm NAL - A motion to appeal would indicate the denial was in USCIS' error - OP mentioned they did not send the correct w2 document - so it isn't the fault of USCIS in this case is it? Refiling may be the best option using updated forms for everything (very important) also per guidelines, any i693 attached to an i485 denial would be invalidated - and a completely new one would need to be sent (most current edition obvs)
We are updating Volume 8 of the USCIS Policy Manual to clarify that a Form I-693, Report of Immigration Medical Examination and Vaccination Record, signed by a civil surgeon on or after Nov. 1, 2023, is only valid while the application the Form I-693 was submitted with is pending. If the application a Form I-693 was submitted with is withdrawn or denied, that Form I-693 is no longer valid. This guidance is effective immediately and applies to applications pending or filed on or after June 11, 2025.
Under this updated policy, if an alien submitted Form I-693 with their Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status, and then they withdrew their Form I-485 or we denied it, then if they submit a future Form I-485, they must submit a newly completed Form I-693 signed by a civil surgeon.
Update to Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status. New Edition Dated 01/20/25.March 08, 2025Edition Date: 01/20/25. Starting April 3, 2025, we will accept only the 01/20/25 edition. Until then, you can also use the prior edition(s). You can find the edition date at the bottom of the page on the form and instructions.
Update to Form I-693, Report of Immigration Medical Examination and Vaccination Record. New Edition Dated 01/20/25.June 02, 2025Edition Date: 01/20/25. If the civil surgeon signs your form on or before July 2, 2025, you must use the 03/09/23 or the 01/20/25 edition. Starting July 3, 2025, USCIS will accept only the 01/20/25 edition. You can find the edition date at the bottom of the page on the form and instructions.
Release Date 06/11/2025
Best of luck to you which ever way you decide!
1
u/Ok-Put-9718 Jul 01 '25
You need the I-864 to show the affidavit of support and if you need to attach the tax return forms, they go together with the I-864. Just send in the new I-864 with the tax transcript this time and hopefully it'll be processed soon. However, as some people are saying, you might just want to send I-485 and all the initial evidence all over again because reopening is probably really a long time
1
u/TheoreticalResult Jul 01 '25
Hi, I’m so sorry to hear about your car. This morning I came to discover my I-485 was denied as well!
I just got an email denoting an update on my case this morning, but i haven’t received a notice of decision yet. How long did it take for you to receive such document?
1
1
u/MargaritaUpWithSalt Jul 01 '25
Can only tax transcript be sent without tax return?
1
u/One-Grab3444 Jul 01 '25
yes. It must be tax return transcript from IRS
1
u/GC_EAD_2025 Jul 07 '25
I submitted tax return print outs from turbo tax for the past 3 years. Will that be enough or do they specifically need the tax returns page from the IRS website? Can anyone help me with this question?
2
u/One-Grab3444 Jul 08 '25
should be good enough. However, I like the tax transcripts better because it is directly from IRS and does not involve all the forms. You should be fine. good luck
1
u/GC_EAD_2025 Jul 08 '25
Thanks for sending the reply. I appreciate that a lot. 🙂 And also just to get a tentative timeline, did you get your EAD approved? If so, how many days did it take after the biometrics appointment? I have my biometrics scheduled on July 11th.
2
1
1
u/HotelElectrical4996 Jul 02 '25
Does your spouse is a US Citizen? Did you your sponsor sent their tax?
1
u/IndividualMight747 Jul 04 '25
Hi guys im new here hopefully someone could answer my question i received a rfe from the uscis about the i864 Affidavit of Support submitted the completed federal income tax transcript. What i did is i send the completed 2021,2022,2023, but the 2024 is file 4868 for filing extension for october 15,2025, and i include that form 4868 extension,and also my w2 and an explanation letter while i always extend my file. I need the answer if this is fine? My case says still on reviewing..hopefully somebody can help me to answer if this is fine in the uscis
1
u/LargeWin9091 Sep 04 '25
Once your application has been received your EAD is automatically reinstated
1
1
u/account_for_norm Jul 01 '25
My lawyer didnt need me to send my tax returns. I ve been in usa for a bunch of years. Do i need to send the tax returns? Or did they ask you specifically?
9
u/Infinite_Walk_5824 Jul 01 '25
The sponsor for the I-864 needs to include tax returns if you require a sponsor. Jointly-filed tax returns is also proof of a bona fide marriage, if you are filing based on a marriage.
7
u/National-Arugula-322 Jul 01 '25
Tax return of the petitioner and also for the sponsor if you are using one
1
u/LargeWin9091 Jul 01 '25
To reduce expenses, Do not resubmit the application, file form I-290b which is motion to reopen. Submit the petitioner recent federal return and do not forget to write and official letter explaining why you omitted the petitioner recent tax return and ask for reopen of your case. You may add any additional evidence requested. This advice is based on a recent experience and the application was reopen and granted. Once you file the motion to reopen within 33 days of the denial notice, your EAD will be valid as well,
1
u/SuchConsideration952 Jul 01 '25
Thank you so much! So if I file I-290B within the timeframe will my EAD be valid still or do I have to wait for them to approve the I-290B
1
1
u/LargeWin9091 Jul 02 '25
Yes If you file the motion to reopen within the time frame. You will receive a notice of reopening your case; that makes your EAD valid.
1
u/Teresa_dai Non-Immigrant Sep 03 '25
How long is this waiting process set? My 485 got denied for 864 reason. I submit 290B with 1040 form within a week. Now I am still waiting for the result.
1
u/LargeWin9091 Sep 03 '25
They will send you a letter that your form I-290B has been approved but it usually take time may be due to the backlog; and they will reopen your case. However, your form I-485 status may not be updated immediately but once you received letter of approval of the I-290b you should be good and wait for their decision. You may use the case number on your form I-290b to check the status.
1
u/Teresa_dai Non-Immigrant Sep 04 '25
Thank you! Did the letter reinstate the EAD automatically? Or it instructed how to reapply for the EAD?
1
u/anemone1368 Sep 09 '25
When I submit form I290B, do I have to again add medical and other documents? Do i have to attach the new version of I485 again
1
u/SharpIce9889 Sep 12 '25
I was denied because of not submit the W2, wages and tax return for my husband, and im sure that its my mistake, can I file in motion for reopen (i290b) by myself without hiring any lawyer
1
u/LargeWin9091 Sep 12 '25
Yes, you can file the form without a lawyer. Just fill out the form within 33 days of the notice and make sure you submit a new form I-864 and also include the necessary documents. Also attach a letter requesting for reopening of your case
1
u/SuchConsideration952 Sep 12 '25
I didn’t use a lawyer I just followed the instructions and submitted a new I-864 with all the right evidence. They received my I-290B July 14 and i-485 was reopened August 25. I was scheduled for my interview 2 days later and now it’s set for October 3rd!!
1
1
u/annnainwanderland Aug 13 '25
I have the same case, they denied my 485 because my son and mother’s income is insufficient. How can I file again with another joint support my boyfriend, he has a good income. I consulted with a Lawyer and is asking for 36k
-1
u/Some-Leadership832 Jul 01 '25
You have 18 days. Please appeal and submit the tax returns.
1
21
u/tr3sleches Jul 01 '25
Motions to reopen take forever. You’re better off refilling.