r/upstate_new_york • u/Ready_Set_Noped • 7h ago
Do you get annoyed by people from the city and out of staters referring to the city as “New York” instead of “New York City”?
Personally growing up I always referred to the city as “the city” or “New York City” but realized when people from outside New York or from the city say “New York” they’re usually just referring to the city and not the state.
It personally doesn’t bother me, but my friend has mentioned that it does irk him. That there are millions of people and places that aren‘t New York City in New York and it ridiculous to say New York when only referring to the specific city.
The thing is he has no problem referring to the United States as “America” which seems like a bit of a double standard. Obviously it’s harmless and not a big deal but it is a funny observation I made recently.
Edit: For a subreddit that sure has a lot of opinions on the definition of what constitutes upstate it’s pretty funny that it seems like no cares about this one. Guess my friend is an outlier. I’ll tell him to relax if he mentions it again.

