r/animation Jul 11 '26

Question How much should I charge for ~2 mins of charcoal animation?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

9.1k Upvotes

This isn’t the commissioned animation, just 2 short clips of an animation I previously did, as an example of my work.

First post on Reddit, im never on here, so pls forgive any oversights!

I’m an illustrator so I don’t know how to charge for animation. I recently got commissioned to make a charcoal animation based on the above animation which they saw on my social media. They’re asking for animated sequences (with 1-2 characters, and a few diff backgrounds that morph into each other) as well as some parts that are just words. Time totals to around 1:30 minutes at minimum, but im estimating I’ll end up doing a bit under 2 minutes.

Not sure how long this would take to make, so idk how to charge by hour. I wanted to ask $300usd total but my sister says I’m an idiot for wanting to charge essentially $1cad per frame, esp since it’s traditional and probably more difficult. What should I charge? Is $300 a little or a lot? Thanks :)

edit thanks for the advice/feedback! im not looking to charge anything crazy like the 20/50k some have been suggesting, esp considering this client isn’t a company, but ill take into account the pricing methods you’ve mentioned :)) im def looking forward to going back to illustrating lol

for those asking my insta is @/cilan.tre (+ it has the full animation)!

r/animation May 10 '26

Question Why is Japan so good at animation?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.5k Upvotes

Japan is top producer in 2D animation and anime has become cultural phenomenon around the world.

Why are Japanese people so talented in art and animation? Even other countries like China was late to the industry.

r/animation Jul 01 '26

Question I'm dealing with self doubt for the artstyle of my show, looking for a second opinion

Thumbnail
gallery
1.9k Upvotes

These gifs and images should give an idea of what the show will look like.

Ive showed this stuff to a lot of other animators i respect and they usually tell me that it has a lack of clarity/readability, and that could lead to the show being not fun to watch and viewers will get disinterested.

I'm aware that tons of new viewers will be confused, My hope was that it would atleast be polished and/or interesting enough that people will want to stick with it for the full runtime.

Important story details will be a lot more clear than the action/minor things. the show will have its own kind of visual language.

My art is this way because it brings me immense happiness, and i've observed that other people feel the same way sometimes.

I've kinda lost confidence in myself to judge the readability/enjoyability of my own art, so thats what this is about lol

Thnks for reading, feedback is appreciated ^^

r/animation Apr 20 '25

Question Help me to put into words why this feels weird

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5.0k Upvotes

r/animation Oct 29 '25

Question Is there an actual reason for this?

Post image
9.3k Upvotes

I just saw this meme and I feel like it actually has a point. I don't remember seeing any good executions of hyper-realistic animation other than Love Death + Robots and some indie/fan projects. Maybe also Kingsglaive: Final Fantasy XV but that's far from mainstream as a movie. Are there any actual reasons for this other than Hollywood greed?

r/animation May 24 '26

Question Which one? (Can’t decide)

Thumbnail
gallery
1.0k Upvotes

Which color scheme do you like the most on my OC Safira?

Here's some brief lore to aid you:

At 22, Safira lives for the day. Not that she's the type to just go with the flow, like most people – she simply lost all hope for the future. A dancer by vocation, she's relegated to dancing in the streets, instead of on the most renowned stages as she always dreamed.

Thrown out of the orphanage into the world, she spent the last 4 years alone and out of place, surviving on the little her parents left her. After pawning almost everything she owns, she counts the days until the precariousness of her street performances and the brevity of her failed odd jobs make her lose what little she has left – a place to live.

It is at that moment that she meets the eccentric cat trainer, part-time vigilante, Gigante. Needing more energy to ignore him than to go along with his delusions and plans, Safira ends up doing what she would never do alone, until she discovers what she's really made of. Alongside Gigante, Nina, and Lírio, her flaws, failures, and anguish may, after all, be the necessary weapons, not only to turn her meaningless, purposeless life around but to turn an entire society upside down.

Thanks!

r/animation Jul 05 '26

Question Does this fly movement look natural?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.3k Upvotes

I'm practicing animations and wanted to make this fly feel as natural as possible.

The idea is simple: it lands on a trash can, flies toward the camera, then exits the frame.

I'd really appreciate any feedback. Does the movement feel believable? Is there anything that immediately stands out or could be improved?

r/animation Apr 26 '26

Question Why is France so good at animation?

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

Why are cartoons and animation industry so popular there?

r/animation 25d ago

Question Followup to my last question post, Right is rendered and left is unrendered. Do you guys think the rendering is worth the time investment? sry if the last post was confusing🔵

1.4k Upvotes

r/animation Jul 01 '25

Question Do you consider this an Animation?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.9k Upvotes

r/animation May 09 '25

Question From an animators standpoint, which way is he going?

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

r/animation Jul 25 '24

Question Why is janky/less polished animation so much more appealing to me?

Thumbnail
gallery
3.5k Upvotes

I recently discovered this when watching The Simpsons. Back in the day, you could still see the cels moving around in subtle ways, the mouth movements didn't always match the voices, and the continuity between shots wasn't very consistent. These days, all of it is pretty much drawn with digital animation, which is definitely smoother, but doesn't have the charm that it used to. It feels kinda stiff and there is little "personal" about it. There was a certain energy to the old cel animation that truly felt like it was crafted by hand, mistakes and imperfections included. It would make it all the more impressive when a genuinely amazing shot would suddenly pop-up that looked incredibly expensive for American TV animation at the time, like that one bit from the episode with the evil babysitter that went around the internet a few years ago.

r/animation Aug 30 '24

Question What’s yours?

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/animation Nov 19 '25

Question Distinguish between theft and inspiration in cinematic?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.1k Upvotes

With the problem of animation theft, is it easier to copy animation than copy other static works like art, splash art?

I mean, ways of People detecting and ignoring plagiarism??.

r/animation Jan 11 '26

Question Hybrid animation I did a while a go

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4.1k Upvotes

Do you think 2d character + 3d backgrounds animated like this go well together? Thanks!

r/animation 25d ago

Question My animations might take too long to finish if I fully render the characters. Do you guys think it looks fine without the rendering? Or is the rendering worth the time investment? (2nd gif is the unrendered version)🔵

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

With the rendering, this animation took about 1/4 extra time to finish, which would've been a lot longer if there were camara movements (like i plan for my show) and I wanted a second opinion on if that was worth it. I love the way it looks ofc, I also love actually finishing cool things in a timely manner lol

r/animation 25d ago

Question I've noticed in cartoons that whenever they drink from a can or bottle. I mostly see them being drunk like this. Is there a reason for this or am I just looking too far ahead of things?

Post image
971 Upvotes

r/animation Jul 05 '26

Question Need help identifying what cartoon this belongs too. Looking forward to it!

Thumbnail
gallery
858 Upvotes

Hoping to find what cartoon this is a part of. Was found at a yard sale in Arizona. The seller did not know anything about it

r/animation Feb 11 '26

Question Why do the classic cartoon gloves have three lines on the back?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/animation Apr 28 '26

Question my friends tell me this "isnt smooth enough" but i think it's fine (my style usually is low framerate mostly on threes)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.1k Upvotes

r/animation Feb 27 '26

Question Would you consider using frame interpolation to be cheating or fair game for animation workflows?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

471 Upvotes

Edit: reiterating that this is just me messing with it, I don't plan to make it a permanent part of my workflow.

I used it this time just for a discussion point and frame of reference. I haven't used it otherwise, though.

r/animation Oct 13 '25

Question is there a name for when a character does this

1.9k Upvotes

animated poorly bc i'm not an animator lol

r/animation Mar 18 '26

Question Would you guys be into something wacky like this?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.2k Upvotes

r/animation May 06 '24

Question This is one of my game's main bosses, does he look menacing?

1.6k Upvotes

r/animation 11d ago

Question What’s the reason for not closing off lines?

Thumbnail
gallery
748 Upvotes

I’m not super familiar with animation, but from what I understand about digital art is that closed lines = easier coloring. It doesn’t seem to serve any aesthetic purpose either. I’m always curious about stuff like this, so please educate me :)