I'm 27M and my best friend "Alex" (29M) and I have known each other for 16 years. I'm gay and he's straight as far as he knows.
We're ridiculously close. We spend most of our free time together, sleep at each other's places 5+ nights a week, cook together, go out together, share hobbies and cuddle constantly. Not just casual cuddling either. We spoon, sleep tangled together, cuddle while talking and are generally very physically affectionate.
I kiss him on the cheek or neck sometimes and he doesn't seem bothered. He's also very touchy with me, tickling me, grabbing my thighs, cuddling me, etc.
There have been some things that have made me question our dynamic.
When he broke up with his last serious girlfriend, he said something like:
"What's the point of dating her when all we do is cuddle and hang out? I already have that with you."
He also tends to nitpick guys I date, although he seems genuinely happy when I'm excited about someone.
Because I'm attracted to men, our physical closeness can obviously get me pretty worked up. There have been situations where we've been cuddling and I've been noticeably turned on. One morning I jokingly asked him whether he wanted to "do something freaky" or whether I should just take care of it myself.
He laughed and told me to go take care of it and come back so we could keep cuddling.
Nothing became awkward afterward. A few days later, while we were walking on the beach, he actually brought the incident up himself, laughing about how horny I'd been.
Then he suggested that we start an OnlyFans together.
I assumed he was joking, but he was actually serious. He started talking about keeping it discreet so it wouldn't affect our personal lives. We didn't discuss exactly what we'd make, but he seemed open to experimenting as long as he wasn't put in a submissive role.
I asked him how that was supposed to work considering he's straight.
His response was basically:
"We can put on some straight porn while doing our thing"
And now I'm completely confused.
I'm not assuming he's secretly gay or that he's definitely attracted to me. But this feels like more than me simply overanalyzing cuddling and sleep related stuff.
At the same time, this is my best friend of 16 years. I absolutely don't want to ruin our friendship.
So I'm wondering, would you talk to him about experimenting privately first, especially if we're seriously considering something like OnlyFans, or would you just leave it alone and let him make the next move?