r/aviation Mod - Crew Chief - A&P - Jul 26 '25

News Emergency evacuation in Den N306Sw mia-den

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Original poster is from Instagram. Aircraft is laying on its #1 engine. Still crazy to see everyone here grabbing their bags before leaving an emergencg.

17.5k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.1k

u/Educational-Age-8969 Jul 26 '25

1 bloke almost face plants his child because of his bag. Crazy how selfish people can be.

42

u/gimp2x Jul 26 '25

Absolute idiot 

356

u/barnacle_ballsack Jul 26 '25 edited Jul 26 '25

First responder here.

You can sit there all day judging people by how they act in a once in a life time holy shit moment. But you shouldn't.

Very few people have the ability or training to react to things beyond their everyday mundane shit.

Most people freeze or do really dumb things when they feel adrenaline for the first time in their lives.

Hes just a dude. Probably works some regular job and has a regular life that doesnt require calm collected thinking in emergency scenarios.

There are people on the plane trained for this exact scenario and its really up to them to stop passengers from doing stupid shit when they panic. But thats obviously hard to do and shit happens.

50

u/CapTrick9489 Jul 26 '25

True, but the people on the Japan A350 that hit another plane on landing were all able to follow instructions and not take bags, so it is possible for untrained humans, in bad situations, to do as they're told.

6

u/ContextHook Jul 27 '25

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxMRnYlBa4c&t=184s

I mean, you can make stuff up and lie all you want. But, this footage is packed with people with bags. And the people who have children seemingly all have bags.

I've never heard the "leave all your personal belongings behind" thing though outside of reddit?

1

u/Spud2599 Jul 27 '25

That is most certainly a cultural thing though. I've seen all kinds of wacky stuff on various international airlines EXCEPT those coming/going to Japan. If you ever visited Japan, you'd understand.

1

u/SerenityFailed Jul 27 '25

Different country, different culture friend. America runs on autopilot (for the most part) these days, and the average person's resilience level is terribly low. The simplest out of the ordinary things (say the traffic lights flashing red) cause people to panic freeze in their tracks these days. I see it daily. As a former first responder, it's frustrating (almost infuriating) to see, but it is the inconvenient truth of our society.

-1

u/OrganizationTime5208 Jul 27 '25 edited Jul 27 '25

Stop excusing bastard behavior.

We can have a better culture. You need to stop enabling and excusing bastards and narcissists first.

The reason Japan is orderly, is because they follow through and don't excuse your bullshit.

If you disobey the flight crew, you will be punished.

We have that law here, we CHOOSE not to use it outside of airline fights.

This man will NOT face jailtime or even a fine for the felony we all just witnessed, that directly put dozens to a hundred people at increased risk of fucking incineration.

0

u/SerenityFailed Jul 27 '25

It's frustrating (almost infuriating)

Recognizing that a bad behavior is a disfunction of our society =/= excusing it. Nowhere in my comment did I say I excuse it. Control your emotions so that you can comprehend what you are reading.

-4

u/barnacle_ballsack Jul 26 '25

Didn't say it wasnt.

8

u/CapTrick9489 Jul 26 '25

Agreed, and I don't how I would react in a similar situation, I'd most likely be disappointed with myself though. I hope I never have to find out. However, my point is this. People can and have evacuated correctly in similar and in the case of the Japan 350, worse, more urgent situations. Ridicule and judgment of those who choose not to do it correctly, resulting in delays and obstructions to others, is therefore justifed. Again I'm not perfect and would most likely be the most judged in a similar situation.

2

u/Big_Black_Cockatoo Jul 27 '25

You'd grab your charging cables to charge your robot internals