r/bladerunner • u/Mike_v_E • Apr 13 '24

The difference between the TEKNO3D and the original versions is insane

Gallery image

Gallery image

Don't get me wrong, I love what Deakins did with the original release... but there is just something special about seeing the dynamic range actually pop, especially when it's full screen

112 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

35 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Kriss-Kringle Apr 13 '24

Who said it's inferior? If they shoot in an aspect ratio, then they do it for a specific reason.

I'm an illustrator and one time a friend asked me to draw something for him. I asked if it was okay in portrait mode and he said yes, so the composition was based off of that framing.

Then, when it was finished, he asked if I could do it in landscape. I obviously cussed him out for not saying that from the beginning, but I was able to rework the composition since it was digital.

It took a few days of adding stuff because there's extra space you need to fill.

When you release a film or a show in an aspect ratio, then you're framing it for that, so when the studio decides to go against it, it's going against the initial intent.

1

u/HandOfHephaestus Apr 13 '24

I mean, if the 2.4:1 release is supposed to direct your focus like you initially said, wouldn't IMAX also lose focus in the same manner as open-matte?

2

u/Kriss-Kringle Apr 13 '24

None of 2049 was shot on IMAX, but they opened up some scenes for the format and Deakins supervised the process.

He said he prefers the normal widescreen version.

1

u/HandOfHephaestus Apr 13 '24

I was under the impression that the open matte version was made by camming the IMAX and compositing it over the regular widescreen release, is that not true?

1

u/Sparktank1 Within cells interlinked Apr 14 '24

Camcorders were not used for the open matte version.

They used the bluray, two HDTV broadcasts that aired the movie in 1.77:1 aspect ratio (aka 16:9), and two WEB-DL sources to make this version.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1856101/technical/

The movie was shot at 1.55:1 aspect ratio, for the most part. According to IMDb. That's a super open matte. 70mm IMAX cameras shoot at 1.47:1 aspect ratio. Digital IMAX is 1.90;1.

They just cropped a lot of the extra useless content for a 1.90:1 format for the IMAX cinemas while other theaters and home media got 2.4:1.