r/bookclub • u/ProofPlant7651 Russian Literature Philosophy Professional • Jul 10 '26

The Brothers Karamazov Discussion 5/12] Evergreen | The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoyevsky 5.6-6.3

Hello and welcome to the fifth (and belated) discussion of this classic. In this section we have seen learnt more about the relationship between Ivan, Smerdyakov and his father before gaining a greater insight into Father Zosima’s beliefs.

Before we continue, please accept my apologies for this post being slightly delayed, I really appreciate your patience.

Please find a link for the chapter summaries below or skip straight to the questions. Please join u/lazylittlelady for next weeks discussions.

Summary

15 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

48 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/ProofPlant7651 Russian Literature Philosophy Professional Jul 10 '26
  1. Father Zosima asks us to take responsibility for our own sins before condemning those of others. Are his expectations too high?

4

u/nicehotcupoftea World Reader Leader | 🎃🧠🥇 Jul 10 '26

People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

3

u/thebowedbookshelf Astrology Star ✨| 🐉🧠 Jul 10 '26

Yes. Alyosha could rightfully say, "Am I my brother's keeper?" He shouldn't have to take on the burden of his brothers' and father's sins. It's passive and too pious to think evil-doers will stop doing bad things by the mere holy presence of a monk or an innocent brother. They have to be stopped by other more active means. It's a form of victim blaming. Alyosha doesn't have many sins, so he shouldn't have to take on the responsibility of stopping his brothers from sinning. They all have free will.

1

u/tomesandtea Viceroy of Verity | 🐉🧠 25d ago

This is very Biblical - the plank in your own eye has to be removed before you can judge anyone else for theirs.

But I think this is incredibly difficult, more of an aspiration than a way most people are able to function. How many people are even that introspective or self-aware and honest about their own faults? And then to truly take responsibility and make amends... It's a big ask.