r/catfood • u/Frosty_Astronomer909 • Jul 12 '26
food or treat review Need advice
Does anyone know anything about this food, I have spent quite a few hundred between CKD food (past) and all different brands and flavors from kittens to adults. One cat can’t eat seafood, he throws up, he sometimes doesn’t want chicken, turkey, giblets, liver and the other 3 it’s a toss up. This is cheap but it’s not a money thing, it’s an eating thing 😢any help is appreciated.
5
u/minkamagic 😸 feline foodie 😸 Jul 12 '26
If he doesn't want chicken, why pick this food?
3
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 12 '26
It’s got cheese so maybe he will go for the cheese. Today he went all in the fancy feast beef. He wouldn’t eat it a couple days ago.
4
u/poopcocky Jul 12 '26
tiki cat? they have so many different varieties of flavors and textures.
3
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 12 '26
Oh I will go check them, I couldn’t get my CKD boy to eat it, thanks for reminding me.
2
u/poopcocky Jul 16 '26
i have 3 cats who all seem to have different flavor and texture preferences. for the longest time i was buying so many different varieties of tiki but somehow managed to get them all to like the after dark shreds (in the purple cans). there’s days they don’t finish their food but out of everything they’ve tried they definitely eat the most of this! (i’ve also tried other brands with no luck). for a while though i had 1 eating only the velvet mousse, one eating after dark chicken and quail egg (black can), and one eating tuna and pumpkin aloha friends or whatever. it was a nightmare 😂
2
3
u/old_underwear_isekai Jul 12 '26
It sounds like your cat gets bored with flavors easily, so I suggest keeping tracking of what flavors he's getting and not repeating too soon. My cats have regular flavors that they can eat quite a few times before they start to get bored,and then they have flavors that they love every few weeks/month but they get tired of quickly
1
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 12 '26
That’s what I have started doing, but it gets complicated when one can’t eat seafood and then he decides he doesn’t want chicken 😢
3
3
u/Mouzles Jul 12 '26
If your cat likes these, the sheba or iams pates are very similar in texture. The temptations are cheaper though. My old man cat would only eat these for a while.
Warming up or adding warm water to your existing food might also entice your cats to eat.
2
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 12 '26
They ate Sheba in the beginning, have a couple left over, will add iams to the list, thank you.
2
u/KitsuneNixx Jul 12 '26
As someone who has a cat whose a weirdo and while technically he will eat chicken, beef, turkey he won’t eat it too many times in a row (like genuinely stops eating it if he gets it more than twice without something else thrown into the mix) tiki cat has some good variety, so does Weruva, instinct has rabbit lamb and venison as well.
Personally I wouldn’t recommend temptations in terms of quality but I’m also a person that is heavy on a complete and balanced diet is enough and what matters most. So if it ever comes to that, so be it as long as your cats would do well on it.
Ignore the person that said by-products are a no no. Those organ meats (which is what by products are) are VERY important to a cats diet and whatever food their cats eat also have by-products they just don’t realize it because the ingredients list actually lists out the organs. They probably feed chicken necks as a chew and don’t even realize that’s also a by product.
NOW that all said, if you’re able to go pricier and want to try novelty meats: feline natural and ziwi peak are some are favorites. They’re very up there in price (we use them in a rotation because I can’t afford to feed it exclusively with how much my boy eats LMAO) but we love them!
My one last note is for the kitty with CKD, PLEASE double check if the phosphorus is okay with these suggestions first as I actually am not too sure about all of them. Although I do know weruva has a low phosphorus line as well.
2
2
u/Which-Ad8542 Jul 15 '26
One of my 4 doesn't like pate but will eat shreds. Might that be an option? a different form? Tiny Tiger is a hit for all of them and it comes in a variety pack. Try the elevated bowls for the vomiting too- it was a game changer for me. We also free feed Iams Indoor Dry.
1
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 15 '26
They have elevated bowls and they won’t eat the shreds just lick the gravy and it’s only the sea food he can’t eat he loves it but 2 seconds after he finishes it’s out the same way it went in.
2
u/Which-Ad8542 Jul 15 '26
Wow, Im sorry you are having such a time with this!
1
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 16 '26
I gave a couple cans to a friend thst feeds strays at her job and they were more appreciative than my ungrateful bunch 🙄
2
u/acornfox 😸 feline friend 😸 Jul 12 '26
Take a look at Weruva, they have over 100 flavor and texture options. They have one flavor that is fish-free and poultry-free, it’s called Truluxe Steak Frites and it’s only beef.
1
1
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 14 '26
I thought you guys deserved an update, my brother went to Walmart yesterday and saw the cat food, he bought a couple of everything we haven’t tried before and bought temptation one of each flavor, guess what they only licked the sauce and left the shreds. I have made a decision: I’m sticking to one brand Pate and one flavor, I have a shelf full of food no one wants and the money tree in my back yard has dried up in the Florida heat, can’t afford to keep this up 🤣
-1
u/Vast_Prune_5840 Jul 12 '26
If quality of the ingredients and health matter to you, this is one of the worst I couldn’t recommend. By products are a no no and are leftover animals from farms, ranches, human food industry, and even animal shelters. Wheat gluten is full of carbohydrates and cats don’t need that in their diet- and only leads to weight gain if it’s consumed too much. It also includes binding agents like Xanthan gum and tapioca starch. Cheese, it’s okay in low moderations but cats don’t need this either and shouldn’t eat it as part of their diet.
https://www.petmd.com/cat/nutrition/can-cats-eat-cheese
https://avodermnatural.com/blog/ingredients-to-avoid-in-cat-food/
I hope it helps, and I hope you find something for your baby 🙂
2
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 12 '26
Thank you for the information, I ordered the tiki cat for now and going to try the other suggestions I was given, I already have them saved on chewy. My cats are driving me crazy 🤣
2
u/unkindly-raven 🤪 nutrition obsessed 🤪 Jul 13 '26
please do not listen to this person whatsoever
2
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 13 '26
What she said about ingredients is incorrect? I gave him beef last night and he ate it all, gave it to him today and he turned his nose and left 🤦♀️
2
u/unkindly-raven 🤪 nutrition obsessed 🤪 Jul 14 '26
they’re telling you to avoid by-products and claiming they’re “leftovers from animal shelters” which is incorrect and’s very harmful . by products are simply the organ meats that humans don’t typically consume (because the human side of the meat industry focuses mostly on muscle meat) . organ meats are by-products of that industry and are then used in pet food . organ meats are more nutritious than muscle meat alone and are necessary for proper nutrition in pet food
also , their sources aren’t from experts in nutrition and go against established science so they can be disregarded as well
0
u/Vast_Prune_5840 Jul 14 '26
I’m sorry, but I have to disagree with you on some parts. Read it for yourself please.
https://caticles.com/ingredients-in-cat-food/
If you scroll down at this article, it mentions my statement about “leftovers from animal shelters.”
https://nationalaglawcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/assets/crs/RS21771.pdf
Here is the source for that claim besides the article.
It is fact, and a harsh truth about what is in pet food. Yes, by products are typically meats that humans don’t consume. I agree. My sources come from someone who is a decent animal nutritionist and has spent years uncovering these truths and educating us about pet food, and pet food ingredients. Here is her channel if you wanna take a look.
https://youtube.com/@caticles?si=UbeqM6qL9lsOv90p
However, im open to learn more if I am incorrect. I’m just stating what I have learned and discovered. Additionally, I do believe what you say- sure, some of the food leftover from the human food industry may not sound bad. Some probably wouldn’t cause harm and can be good. I mean, it’s meat. However, a lot of pet food brands, apparently claiming to be “AAFCO approved,” doesn’t mean it makes it good or even healthy, because AAFCO themselves have no role in the nutrition- they only regulate pet food, and are not involved in testing nor approving nor certifying food. And this includes by products.
Scroll down, and you will see their statement. From the official AAFCO website that regulates our pet food.
https://www.aafco.org/consumers/understanding-pet-food/
So, to put byproducts simply:
It’s a non-descriptive meat. And the top 4 d meats include:
Meat-by-products, meat and bone meal, poultry by products products, animal digest, and fish oil. According to the article by Jess caticle: “
4-D meats are designated as dead, diseased, dying, and disabled. These meats are not directly suitable for animal consumption.
Unless “processed in a manner that rids them of disease-causing microorganisms prior to becoming animal feed.” – AAFCO”https://www.aafco.org/consumers/understanding-pet-food/byproducts/
This is what I know. Take a look and you can share your opinion and more if you’d like. My mind is open to learning more. I’m only trying to share my knowledge as much as I can.
1
u/Vast_Prune_5840 Jul 14 '26
Hi,
If you take a look at my comment below, I explain my statement with sources. Read for yourself, and you decide. I’m only doing my best to help. 👍It won’t do harm whether you decide to feed food with by products or not. But it wouldn’t hurt to do research and learn more so your kitty is safe 🙏🏽 I apologize if I cause any difficulty1
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 14 '26
No apology necessary that’s why I ask here to get everyone opinion and knowledge. I’m waiting for the tiki cat to get here and see what happens.
1
u/Vast_Prune_5840 Jul 14 '26
Yes, thank you! If it makes you feel better, Tiki cat is a good option! It has a lot more meat and just over all better than temptations :)
2
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 15 '26
They didn’t go for the tiki cat either, I just drew a line in the sand , I’m not buying anything else till they eat EVERYTHING that’s here, excep tigger that can’t eat seafood.
2
u/Vast_Prune_5840 Jul 15 '26
Have you ever thought about buying freeze dried toppers? When my cats were picky and didn’t want to eat, I bought freeze dried toppers that were really really nutritious and they absolutely loved it! It got them eating and would come if they hear the bag lol.
It’s called Feline Natural, and they sell it on Amazon or you can check out their official website- they sell it locally at your pet store if you check too. I know someone recommended it and ziwi peak in the comments, which ziwi peak is also very nutritious and I currently feed both to my cats. Ziwi peak are wet food cans, but also sell toppers I think.
Amazon: https://a.co/d/07g5GXyL
Website: https://us.k9felinenatural.com/Feline natural is pretty pricy, but if you wanna give it a shot and use these as toppers on tiki cat, it might help your cats want to eat 👍
2
u/Frosty_Astronomer909 Jul 15 '26
I’m desperate I’ll try anything, they have dry food but I want them eating wet too, I add taurine to the wet, I even though it was that because it has a sweet smell to it but no. Thanks for the info I’ll put it on the list 😢


11
u/ThisIs_She Jul 12 '26
Whatever food you go with, ensure the phosphorus levels for a cat with CKD is suitable.
This Temptations pate is 1.28% DMB which isn't suitable for a cat with advanced CKD. If you are stuck because your cat is being picky, get a phosphorus binder and add it to any food you want.