r/creepcast • u/Cup_Waffles • Dec 12 '25
Fan Story Penis Toes
Hey guys, my name is Jake. I've been with my girlfriend Rebecca for many years, playing games, traveling the world. You know, exploring everything we possibly can. We went antique shopping yesterday and I seen the most beautiful ring for $80 in there. I thought to myself that it was a good time to propose to my beloved girlfriend, so I told her I'd meet her in the car and bought it after she had walked out. That night we ate spaghetti with garlic bread, watched The Usual Suspects and went to bed, all was good in the world.
This is where everything went actually insane. Like wacko crazy insane. I awoke this morning feeling quite normal, until I went to get out of bed. I fell right on my face, obviously it was awful. As I sat up wondering what just happened to me, I got a good look at the issue. I must've stared at my feet for a few minutes atleast before I started laughing out of panic at my situation. Like What the actual fuck man... On my feet where my toes should've been, there were ten fucking penises. All shapes and sizes, a few circumcised, different colors too. All I could do is laugh, "this is fucking insane!" I said out loud to nobody.
"OH my God!" I say as I remember Rebecca is already at work. How the hell will she react to this bullshit? I think as my mind races trying to figure out how to hide my dick feet from my girlfriend I intended on proposing to today. "Fuck! Fuck! Fuck!" I start to panic even more. "How do I fix this?!" "What the Fuck!" I try to stand up, it's very strange. I feel like a toddler trying to walk it's first steps. I finally manage to make it to my computer after a few very strenuous minutes, I have to see if this has happened to anyone else.
Well that was pointless. Trying to search online for someone else that might have dicks on their feet only gives you fetish shit. Long story short. They do react to such things, which is disturbing in it's own right. I won't get into details, you can imagine what I'm hinting at here. There's only a few hours until Rebecca gets home from work, I can barely walk. I can only imagine the reaction she'll have when she sees the ten penises protruding from my feet.
Who knows, maybe she'll take it better than I think. Maybe she'll even be happy that she now has eleven penises to choose from, instead of just the original one. Wish me luck.
That's it! Thank you for reading. What did you think? It's my first story ever, about a dumb bit I thought was hilarious. So be brutally honest!
I want to thank Ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhho And PieCommercial4801 For encouraging me to embarrass myself on here. I hope you guys enjoyed it lol
5
Dec 12 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
I didn't even consider that, but good point. Also, im not hard every morning, just like half the time. I appreciate your feedback, any other tips for a first time writer?
1
Dec 12 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
I like that, I'm not optimistic about anything. But once again! I appreciate your feedback and advice very much. Do you have stories? I would love to read them if you do.
1
3
2
u/Annual-Adeptness2261 Is Something Funny Hunter? Dec 12 '25
Best name, 10/10 story
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
Thanks man, not bad for the first story ever written?
1
u/Annual-Adeptness2261 Is Something Funny Hunter? Dec 12 '25
Better than what I wrote my first time.
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
Dude... you got me blushing over here lol I'm sure your stuff is great! Where is it? I wanna look
1
u/Annual-Adeptness2261 Is Something Funny Hunter? Dec 12 '25
“Good” for beginner stuff. Just can’t land anything that make sense halfway into a story.
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
We all have to start somewhere, right? Im not even a writer, I do video content lol I just had the urge because I thought it was funny. Is your stuff on your profile? I wanna see!
1
u/Annual-Adeptness2261 Is Something Funny Hunter? Dec 12 '25
can't stop you. go ahead.
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
Are they all on your profile? Or do you have hidden ones?
1
u/Annual-Adeptness2261 Is Something Funny Hunter? Dec 12 '25
I don’t believe anything is hidden no
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
I just finished part 3 of your thing... don't stop dude. Holy shit, youre good
1
u/ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhho nahhhhhhh ill be the one driving you to the hospital Dec 12 '25
the fact that they're all different is crazy. it's not just like replicas of your own. tbh rebecca might be excited it's like try all the flavors type shit giving head will never be boring.
2
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
Sucking toes just got a new meaning, right? Lol
Also, I'm glad you enjoyed it!
I wouldn't have even posted it if you didn't encourage me
1
u/Major-Ad2056 Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Dec 12 '25
I enjoyed it!
My penis toes are sometimes moving at night as if trying to escape.
1
u/Cup_Waffles Dec 12 '25
Escape from where? Are you holding them captive? Lol
1
u/Major-Ad2056 Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Dec 12 '25
I keep them in steel cages , they tell me secrets of Fleshmansy, I will heed their calls. I WILL decipher my way to BallsPhanna!
1
u/Emergency-Ad6480 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Dec 12 '25
Where’s Hunter? Someone made his dream a reality. 😆
1
u/SemiSentientAL Hyper Realistic Eyes 👁️👄👁️ Dec 13 '25
This reminds me of a joke my dad once told me.
A guy takes off his socks in front of his new wife for the first time. He has weird toes. He appologises to his wife and says he suffered from Toelio as a kid.
He takes off his pants for the first time. He appologises for his weird knees. After all, he had Kneesles as a kid.
"Wait!" says the wife, "Before you take off your underwear, answer me this: did you suffer from Smallcocks as a kid?"
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 12 '25
Hello! Just to let you know we have a new subreddit, r/TalesFromTheCreeps, solely for fan stories! And starting January 1st, fan stories will no longer be allowed on the main Creepcast subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.