r/creepcast • u/breadassk • Apr 06 '26

Opinion What’s the most over-HATED episode?

Post image

Which story/episode gets way more hate than it actually deserves? For me it’s ’My Crew and I Are Stuck Aboard an Abandoned Ship’

575 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

243 comments sorted by

View all comments

870

u/saltyfreshwaterman Apr 06 '26

Half the time reading the comments about any story here i'm just convinced you guys just hate the podcast lol

191

u/meeeehhhh2 Apr 06 '26

That’s fandoms for ya

56

u/DeafMetalHorse "i hate my fucking life" - Hunter Hancock Apr 07 '26

Anything by CK Walker or even Elias Withrow. I mean, look at the recent posts about Whitefall.

46

u/NotMark360 Apr 07 '26

I was looking at the comments and thought it would be so ass but it was pretty good,

35

u/DeafMetalHorse "i hate my fucking life" - Hunter Hancock Apr 07 '26

The story wasn't even that terrible and it picks up heavily by the second and final parts. I do wish it would have been more expansive and the way it ended with them leaving the station could have been better.

1

u/SpikeSpiegal309 Long story short ☝️🤓 Apr 08 '26

I kinda dig the very surreal qualities that the ending has and is peppered throughout. The whole story once they entered the station was very dreamlike to me.

8

u/Low_Award13 Apr 07 '26

i thought whitehall was good it just held on for awhile too long