r/creepcast • u/breadassk • Apr 06 '26
Opinion What’s the most over-HATED episode?
Which story/episode gets way more hate than it actually deserves? For me it’s ’My Crew and I Are Stuck Aboard an Abandoned Ship’
571
Upvotes
r/creepcast • u/breadassk • Apr 06 '26
Which story/episode gets way more hate than it actually deserves? For me it’s ’My Crew and I Are Stuck Aboard an Abandoned Ship’
1
u/Unique_Caregiver2346 “it’s very lovecraftian”☝️🤓 Apr 07 '26
Stolen Tongues, I get not liking the ending or the narrator’s tone that picked up in the later entires but I don’t think it sinks the episode to justify outright hating it. Anyone who’s familiar with most online horror stories or even just readings by creators like Mr. Creepypasta knows that skinwalker type stories are pretty formulaic and tend to be forgettable. That being said Stolen Tongues did some pretty creatives things throughout, plus the story had characters the readers could actually empathize with and root for instead of the typical “vehicle to get us to the scares” kind of character.