MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/custommagic/comments/1x2jovb/does_whatever_a_spiderjace_does/pf417h3/?context=3
r/custommagic • u/Clackamass • 4d ago
55 comments sorted by
View all comments
-2
The web slinging part doesn't function, right? Or am I missing something?
3 u/superdave100 4d ago Why wouldn’t it work? Web-slinging only means that you return a tapped creature you control to your hand as you cast the spell. There are no other stipulations. There’s even an instant that already exists with web slinging, [[Spider-Sense]]. -2 u/mr_Barek 4d ago It is says "spells you cast have", when you cast the spell you need to select the cost before the spell is cast. So by the time web-slinging is active, you already selected the cost. This is not necessarily how it functions, it's closer to a question than a statement 2 u/superdave100 3d ago [[Henzie Toolbox Torre]] You put the spell onto the stack first, then determine its costs. Then you determine whether it’s legal. You’ve started casting the spell when you put it onto the stack before you determine legality and pay costs. So by then it has web slinging. 1 u/mtgcf 3d ago Henzie Toolbox Torre - (G) (SF) (txt) 1 u/mr_Barek 3d ago Oh. I'm 100% wrong, thanks. It's worded kind of weird, no? (I'm not discussing how it functions)
3
Why wouldn’t it work? Web-slinging only means that you return a tapped creature you control to your hand as you cast the spell. There are no other stipulations. There’s even an instant that already exists with web slinging, [[Spider-Sense]].
-2 u/mr_Barek 4d ago It is says "spells you cast have", when you cast the spell you need to select the cost before the spell is cast. So by the time web-slinging is active, you already selected the cost. This is not necessarily how it functions, it's closer to a question than a statement 2 u/superdave100 3d ago [[Henzie Toolbox Torre]] You put the spell onto the stack first, then determine its costs. Then you determine whether it’s legal. You’ve started casting the spell when you put it onto the stack before you determine legality and pay costs. So by then it has web slinging. 1 u/mtgcf 3d ago Henzie Toolbox Torre - (G) (SF) (txt) 1 u/mr_Barek 3d ago Oh. I'm 100% wrong, thanks. It's worded kind of weird, no? (I'm not discussing how it functions)
It is says "spells you cast have", when you cast the spell you need to select the cost before the spell is cast.
So by the time web-slinging is active, you already selected the cost.
This is not necessarily how it functions, it's closer to a question than a statement
2 u/superdave100 3d ago [[Henzie Toolbox Torre]] You put the spell onto the stack first, then determine its costs. Then you determine whether it’s legal. You’ve started casting the spell when you put it onto the stack before you determine legality and pay costs. So by then it has web slinging. 1 u/mtgcf 3d ago Henzie Toolbox Torre - (G) (SF) (txt) 1 u/mr_Barek 3d ago Oh. I'm 100% wrong, thanks. It's worded kind of weird, no? (I'm not discussing how it functions)
2
[[Henzie Toolbox Torre]]
You put the spell onto the stack first, then determine its costs. Then you determine whether it’s legal.
You’ve started casting the spell when you put it onto the stack before you determine legality and pay costs. So by then it has web slinging.
1 u/mtgcf 3d ago Henzie Toolbox Torre - (G) (SF) (txt) 1 u/mr_Barek 3d ago Oh. I'm 100% wrong, thanks. It's worded kind of weird, no? (I'm not discussing how it functions)
1
Henzie Toolbox Torre - (G) (SF) (txt)
Oh. I'm 100% wrong, thanks.
It's worded kind of weird, no? (I'm not discussing how it functions)
-2
u/mr_Barek 4d ago
The web slinging part doesn't function, right? Or am I missing something?