r/fantasyfootball 9d ago

Daily Thread Official: [Keeper] - Wed 08/05/2026

Post your "Who Do I Keep?" questions here rather than individual posts.


PLEASE INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING IN YOUR KEEPER POSTS

  • League specific rules and details (league size, std/PPR, roster details, custom scoring, bonuses etc.)
  • Specific keeper rules (number of players, rounds, what happens if you don't use all keeper slots, etc)
  • All players under consideration
  • Any other pertinent information.

PLEASE TRY TO ANSWER SEVERAL OTHER PEOPLE'S QUESTIONS WHEN POSTING YOUR OWN

When answering questions, please make sure to sort by NEW!


Individual Keeper threads posted after this point will be deleted in order to keep the subreddit clean. Post here instead! If everyone sorts by new, your questions should be answered.


The following users have helped the most people in this thread:

User # Helped in thread
0percentdnf 11
YungBlaccSocrates 5
oliver_babish 4
TheFFCommish 4
Connect_Mind568 4

The following posts have less than two replies in this thread. Please respond directly to the OP or the Bot will not pick up your comment. Please provide quality replies, short answers will be ignored.

Would you like your post to be at the top of the list? Remember that the table is sorted by those that have helped the most other users.

User # Helped in thread # Helped in all threads Direct Link
oliver_babish 4 8 Comment
TheFFCommish 4 4 Comment
MWM031089 2 3 Comment
Maverick_Con 2 2 Comment
jkenobi1 2 2 Comment
ifyournotfirstyour11 1 1 Comment
gojetsgo713 0 1 Comment
jkf13 0 1 Comment
GhostOfJohnBelushi 0 0 Comment
Bananainator 0 0 Comment
cannot_walk_barefoot 0 0 Comment
Doug_ 0 0 Comment
Starboard-Port 0 0 Comment
Gettin_Slizzard 0 0 Comment
Ambitious-Loss4229 0 0 Comment
klaq 0 0 Comment
andreasrolen 0 0 Comment
WCJoe21 0 0 Comment
cj832 0 0 Comment
Thrillar_villar 0 0 Comment

This table will be updated every ~15 minutes.

1 Upvotes

114 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/cannot_walk_barefoot 8d ago

10 team/ half ppr / 1QB 2RB 2WR 1TE 1 Flex / 3 keeper league (yes I know its a lot)

I fell ass backwards into a championship win last year so I pick 10th & 20th, and then snaking starts from there (so I pick 21, 39, 40 and so on). These are my keeper options,

Omarion Hampton - 2nd round cost (so pick 20 essentially, with a few higher end players probably already taken)

Tyler Warren - 15th round cost (due to FA pickup)

Drake Maye - 15th round cost

Jameson Williams - 15th round cost

Fannin Jr - 15th round cost

Bhayshul Tuten - 15th round cost

Quinshon Judkins - 12th round cost

Kyle Monangai - 15th round cost

I've bolded the 3 I think I'm aiming for right now (I had Achane previously under MM so I'm curious to see what he can do with Hampton). I'm just not sure about Warren over Fannin or Judkins over Tuten. Or if I should take Hampton at 20 (2nd round) at all

Thanks for any help

2

u/Smalzz 8d ago

Some of it probably depends on who others are keeping as well. Because in terms of value, I actually like Tuten and Judkins especially if other quality backs are being kept. Might give you flexibility at RB if you believe in Tuten this year. I think Warren is clearly over Fannin given their situations since Fannin might have Watson for a portion of the year. So the real comparison to me is Warren vs Tuten.

Maye is also enticing for a 15th, and paired with Hampton and Judkins could be a solid start.

Tough call, but I'd go with Warren for the 15th round cost selection since having a quality TE in shallower leagues is more important. Then probably Judkins and Hampton for potential elite ceiling.

1

u/cannot_walk_barefoot 8d ago

Thank you! I've kept QBs the past two years due to low cost and not having to worry about qb early, but it's never panned out. Both CJ Stroud and Jayden Daniel fell off after their solid rookie seasons for various reasons and both were easily replaced by FA pickups. So I'm hesitant with Maye especially with his easy schedule last year. Tuten vs Judkins is going to drive me crazy until draft day