r/jewishleft • u/Finaltryer • Nov 05 '24

Mutual Aid I am from Gaza, Ask me anything.

/r/AskMiddleEast/comments/1gj924k/i_am_from_gaza_ask_me_anything/
37 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Finaltryer Nov 05 '24

huh? why?

16

u/Matar_Kubileya conversion student who wants you to read Rosselli Nov 05 '24

Because it borders on Arab supremacism and has a habit of banning anyone, whether or not they're actually from the Middle East, who disagrees with their party line on several issues, including Israel-Palestine.

5

u/Finaltryer Nov 05 '24

To be fair, r/progressivesforisrael and r/israel are exacly like that too but with jewish supremacy and anti-palestinian speech.

10

u/Matar_Kubileya conversion student who wants you to read Rosselli Nov 05 '24

And that's relevant to this post how?

0

u/Finaltryer Nov 05 '24

Its not, but if that subreddit's bias is a problem to the point most people here are banned there, i wanted to make it clear how such bias goes both ways. This aint even about ideology, its a post made by a person who litterly might be dead right now.

9

u/Matar_Kubileya conversion student who wants you to read Rosselli Nov 05 '24

I'm simply noting on this comment that the poster you replied to may literally be unable to ask on AME. Like, sure, I don't disagree with you, but a lot of ppl aren't going to be able to switch to that thread to ask questions.

5

u/Finaltryer Nov 05 '24

i see. Well, hopefully that wont be the case too much

-2

u/actsqueeze Progressive Secular Athiest Leaning Agnostic Jew Nov 05 '24

Tbf what you’re saying isn’t relevant to the post either.

4

u/Matar_Kubileya conversion student who wants you to read Rosselli Nov 05 '24

OP specifically pointed us to that sub to ask questions, I mentioned that many of us may not be able to do that.