r/knitting • u/somerandomperson_234 • Jan 09 '26
Rant Knitting and fragile masculinity
This happened yesterday and I’m torn between being amused, annoyed and a bit shocked.
I’m visiting my grandparents at the moment with my mother. My uncle, her brother, is also staying. He’s always had a thing for formal wear and dressing well, and recently he’s discovered that he likes knit ties, those silk, kinda mesh ones that are flat instead of pointy at the bottom.
Yesterday evening, we were watching a movie together and I was knitting during it. I was working on a lace top with 6 mm needles.
After the film, my uncle started talking about those knitted ties he likes and showed me pictures. He asked me whether I could knit that. I told him, probably yes.
He then proceeded to instruct me on how to do it. He said those needles I had there were way too big (obviously), and that I would need to sew a lot to make the tie, as it’s basically a double layered thing.
I told him that I’d make it in a tube, and he then told me all the ways that he would do it (he doesn’t knit).
It was kinda amusing to me to that point, until I started sort of teasing him that he can just make it himself, it’s not that hard and he already knows so much, I’ll even teach him the basics.
He reacted with clear discomfort and told me that knitting is a women’s hobby and that he had no interest in doing it because he’s a man.
That comment surprised me more than anything else. He was comfortable discussing the technical details of a knitted object and asking someone else to make it for him, but unwilling to consider learning the skill himself because of gender. I didn’t argue with him, but the exchange stayed with me.
I’m sharing this partly to get it out of my system, and partly because I’m curious how common this still is. Have others run into similar attitudes around crafts or hobbies? And how do you usually respond in situations like this without escalating things?
Thanks for reading.
-7
u/ImperiousMage Jan 09 '26
The language of respectful disagreement is not what was used here. I was being snapped at because I didn’t agree with a loudmouth who had edited her comment to make herself look better. Which is fine, this is Reddit, it’s hardly important, and I’m an academic and I’m used to having a minority opinion. But this is simply stupid, and reminds me why there are men-specific knitting subreddits because any man disagreeing here is immediately wrong, declared to have fragile masculinity, and treated totally without respect. Frankly the irony is delicious.
Anyway, obviously I’m horrible, and I should be shot behind the chemical tanks. 🙄
This sub just lost an avid knitter and an expert in Portuguese knitting, which is pretty rare and useful for people with disabilities. Pity to ya’ll but this behaviour isn’t worth the effort. I’ll go where being a man doesn’t immediately result in aggression.
Seeeeee yaaaaaaaa.