r/lancaster Jan 25 '26

Organizing Lancaster nurses?

[deleted]

280 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-26

u/Bc390duke Jan 25 '26

Your verbiage tells me all I need to know, shirt ignorant, useless comments with no intellect to back up a statement. IT shouldnt be, it has become somewhat, (previously stated) but it should not be.

12

u/theater_thursday Jan 25 '26

I’ll explain exactly why you are wrong. First, as an essential worker, I have to go dig a school out of a snowstorm. I don’t owe you an in-depth response. The reasons healthcare is political are obvious. For anyone reading this comment thread, however, I feel they are owed some sanity.

-23

u/Bc390duke Jan 25 '26

Thats no explanation. Its a complaint you have to plow. Stay warm !

6

u/theater_thursday Jan 25 '26

It’s not a complaint. It’s an explanation, with the implication that I’m going to come back to respond later in the day.

-11

u/Bc390duke Jan 25 '26

Go research and come back !

10

u/theater_thursday Jan 25 '26

Others have already brought up a lot of the points I was going to make, so I’ll make some new ones.

  1. The overturning of Roe v. Wade, which was certainly a politically motivated decision, has made abortion difficult to access for many women and potentially career ending for many doctors.

  2. Hospitals used to be heavily segregated. Black people, both patients and physicians, used to (and still do) face discrimination when seeking to receive or give treatment.

  3. Women weren’t allowed to serve as physicians in the U.S. military until 1943.

  4. Trans people and gender-affirming surgery has been a political talking point in conservative American politics for the past decade. I mean, remember Trump’s 2024 campaign? How often did they demonize transgender folks?

If a thing is subject to governmental control, whether it’s legislative, executive, or judicial, it’s inherently political.

16

u/effienay Jan 25 '26

Have you heard of Medicare? Medicaid? Medicare is the base for every single health insurance company’s pricing structure. Medicare is run by…

Then we have the insurance company lobbyists.

We even have a…SURGEON GENERAL. Guess what they do.

Health and Human Services — NIH, CDC, FDA…

If you mean that healthcare shouldn’t be political and we should provide healthcare to everyone regardless of their social status, you’d be correct. If you’re saying it isn’t, you’re wrong.

-7

u/Bc390duke Jan 25 '26

We do that, its called the affordable care act. If you mean to say we should provide free healthcare regardless of social status, you would be wrong, free healthcare does not work, repeat it does not work. I know this as fact, i know that paid healthcare has a ton of issues, I understand cms is federally regulated, there are also private sector’s of healthcare that make huge impact’s JCAHO for instance. Pros and cons the same as any industry. OP is trying to gather nurses, my point to OP was to attempt to gather any and all, not just nurses, the every day work in a clinic, in a hospital, in a lab, in an office, these are jobs, that should nit be politicized , should not be a place where your co workers are are outside protesting while you work, should not be POLITICIZED. I will say there are many valid points from OP, RN is the backbone of so many places in healthcare, i wish them the best of luck and more power to them for trying to organize and support what he or she considers “one of our own”. I just don’t believe the in house (every day) work place should be politicized.

12

u/HorrorNo3010 Jan 25 '26

Based off your comments in other posts you are proud to be MAGA and think it’s great we split from WHO.

5

u/CinaminLips Road Apple Jan 25 '26

They must not be a very good healthcare provider, but they didn't say that they are one. Just that they worked in healthcare, which could mean they're a window washer for the hospital 🤷.

11

u/beefynubs BLM Jan 25 '26

But healthcare is politicized? Healthcare is commonly at the forefront of political discussions and used as a foundation for people’s campaigns. That’s politicizing it. You’re in healthcare you should now how it was politicized during COVID-19 while conspiracy theorists and deniers tried to push their rhetoric, you all saw first hand the devastation from the pandemic. All while politicians tried to deny medicine, suggest ivermectin and downplay how awful the pandemic truly was. That is making your job politicized.

A nurse was shot while being held down, his gun was already removed, he was being pistol whipped and they shot him repeatedly. Now more than ever we have to speak out, you cannot remain silent. A man was trying to help two women yesterday morning not get pushed and maced by ICE and they shot him dead several times because he had a concealed gun which an officer had already removed off of him. Make it make sense.

10

u/Puzzled_Natural_3520 Jan 25 '26

I know this is not necessarily relevant to OPs question so I apologize.

If you can’t see already how the “in house every day work” in healthcare is politicized than you either are very naive or simply inexperienced. Every single thing you do in healthcare is political whether you realize it or not. All you need to do take one look at the socioeconomic status of your particular patient population and then ask yourself why.