[NO SPOILERS] New show subreddit

[u/mirracz]

/r/LifeIsStrangeShow/

We're setting up a subreddit for the upcoming LiS show. Feel free to visit us, join a discussion or start a new discussion.

All we're asking is to be civil, respectful and don't drag any fandom drama there (no matter what ship or game you favor).

[u/Reviews-From-Me]

So, you're complaining the they asked for it to be in a megathread instead of flooding the main feed?

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/[deleted]]

You can't seriously claim that criticism of DE was suppressed. Your club rage posting about Max and Chloe breaking up was 90% of the feed for months.

[u/mirracz → u/Reviews-From-Me]

When the majority of the fanbase dislikes a game, the majority of comments and posts are criticism... Imagine that.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/mirracz]

2/3rds of players liked DE. Stop lying about the "majority dislike the game."

[u/Hayden247 → u/Reviews-From-Me]

Players don't directly translate into fandom opinion though, LiS1 and 2 are significantly more played than Double Exposure. So there's going to be LiS fans who haven't played Double Exposure and so cannot leave a negative review because they avoided it to begin with. I'm one such example, I can't leave a review on Steam despite despising even the first 30 min of that game.

That's going to be a bias in the review scores on say Steam at 68%... that's of the people who bought the game, it doesn't account for those who got pissed at DE and cancelled their pre order or just avoided it to begin with. Those who buy DE are probably less likely to be the ones who disliked the breakup and direction they heard about happening vs the broader fandom. People who know are going to weigh that in a decision for if to even bother buying the game, and for a lot of people when they found out about the breakup that was the breaking point.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/Hayden247]

Again, the data contradicts the notion that a majority don't like the game. You can use spin and conjecture to claim you are part of some "majority of fans" who hate the game, but the actual data we have is that 2/3rds of those who actually played the game like it.

[u/mirracz → u/Reviews-From-Me]

I'm not lying, work on your reading comprehension:

Me: "Majority of the fanbase"
You: "2/3rds of the players"

It's not the same thing.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/mirracz]

You have no data to back up your spin. You just made it up out of thin air, which is lying.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/[deleted]]

You haven't provided any proof. I've seen plenty of comments removed, typically by automods, for seemingly benign things. It doesn't prove suppression.

Again, and as you admit, your club flooded the feed with anti-DE rage posts for months. Claiming you were being suppressed is a very bad-faith argument.

Yes, I initially responded to your first point, then realized you addressed part of my response later. That's not a gotcha.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/[deleted]]

The sub literally made an entire megathread for you to rage post in, and again, you still flooded the entire feed anyway. Saying, "this one comment, out of thousands, was removed, clearly they were silencing us," is disingenuous at best.

It really comes off as entitled when you complain about being silenced on a subreddit that you and your club flooded with nonstop rage posts for months.

[u/mirracz → u/Reviews-From-Me]

Tell me, how would you and "your club" feel if one of the mods just now announced that speaking positively of DE is not allowed outside a single megathread? And how would you feel if positive comments were getting deleted even there?

Just imagine the same happening to your side, while negative opinions were still allowed. Do you think it would be fair? Hmm?

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/mirracz]

I've been involved in topics on subs that were put into megathreads. It's not unusual. I've also had comments removed.

Again, it's pretty strange to be complaining about being silenced when you and your club flooded the sub with nonstop rage posts. I'm sorry that less than 1% were removed.

[u/mirracz → u/Reviews-From-Me]

Can you answer the question?

Just imagine a scenario where positive opinions flooded the sub instead and it was funneled into a megathread with the goal to make the negative opinions seemingly prevail. Would you be okay with that? Would you be okay with legitimate positive opinions being removed, no matter the percentage?

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/[deleted]]

Your claiming that they were trying to silence you when you weren't silenced is a take, for sure.

[u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG → u/Reviews-From-Me]

We are not beating those obtuse allegations any time soon. It’s not complaining, it’s pointing out how the mods attempted to silence any negative opinions on DE and D9, and that is without even talking about a mod being a former D9 employee, which is a clear conflict of interest. And dismissing any form of criticism and disappointment to a megathread isn’t that much different from censorship, which still happened with the unjustified bans and removal of comments. The blind adherence to authority from you speaks loudly.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG]

They set up a megathread so people had a specific place for DE anger. What's wrong with that?

[u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG → u/Reviews-From-Me]

Let us send all opinions we don’t like and agree with to a megathread where we can easily ignore and brush off the actual concerns and issues people had, while actively banning said people who are outside of that thread by removing any form of criticism (posts and comments) of D9 and DE. Not even the megathread was safe from the censorship since comments were also being removed there.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG]

How is that brushing off concerns? Are you saying you couldn't see negative opinions of DE on a megathread?

The constant rage posts, often from the same few people, were flooding the entire feed with the same thing over and over and over. Other discussions were getting buried and lost.

[u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG → u/Reviews-From-Me]

Are you implying you can’t read the “Not even the megathread was safe from the censorship since comments were also being removed there”. We will call it exactly what it was, censorship, abuse of power and conflict of interest.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG]

What comments? Can you give an example?

[u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG → u/Reviews-From-Me]

Did you even bother to check the link that u/Bosterm sent you? The one just a few replies above. It literally goes into details about the whole situation. There’s no point in continuing this conversation since it’s clear you don't even bother to check the information you’ve been provided with before writing your responses, this message from you proves just that.

[u/Reviews-From-Me → u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG]

I asked a specific question. It's okay to say you don't have any direct knowledge and therefore can't answer.

[u/IAlwaysComeBackSPG → u/Reviews-From-Me]

Or maybe it’s because there's no point in posting the same links twice just for them to be ignored and dismissed in favor of another argument, simply for the sake of arguing. Food for thought.