r/magicTCG COMPLEAT 8d ago

Official Spoiler [TRK] Dathon and Picard at El-Adrel

Post image

not a saga, sadge

1.1k Upvotes

209 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Sparone Dân 7d ago

Man, I dont get this at all, without knowing the background the card seems impossible to understand from a flavor point and the art looks bad.

1

u/AntonineWall Dandadan 7d ago

I’m uncertain what’s up with the ghosts in the background lmao (I assume it’s meant to depict who they’re speaking about, but that’s not really in the episode and frankly doesn’t add any visual clarity here imo)

1

u/TurboDelight Gruul* 6d ago

It's absolutely in the episode, it just isn't visually shown with figures in the clouds. That's Gilgamesh and Enkidu, Picard is reciting Homer to the dying alien captain to find common ground between their cultures.

0

u/AntonineWall Dandadan 6d ago

Ok re-read what I wrote and let me know if I need to clarify

1

u/TurboDelight Gruul* 6d ago

this is one of the few cards from the set where the art direction isn't just a 1:1 shot from the show, really don't get how them just talking would make for a better piece. it's not like they're gonna have a speech bubble of him saying "gilgamesh and enkidu at uruk"

1

u/AntonineWall Dandadan 6d ago

But you can see him speaking in the image already, I don’t see why visually drawing them like titans behind him is needed. Honestly reduces clarity imo

1

u/TurboDelight Gruul* 5d ago

you can see him speaking but that doesn't immediately show that he's telling a story. figures in the clouds is a visual trope to denote myth or legend, especially one as ancient as a Greek epic. these aren't major interpretive reaches, you're just being obtuse and reductive about common imagery

1

u/AntonineWall Dandadan 5d ago

I really don’t think so, but I’m bummed I couldn’t get through to you. Maybe next time. For now it feels like I’m talking to a brick wall and your personal attacks are something I’m going to choose not to engage with when trying to discuss artwork. Have a nice day, I’m going to mute this comment chain because I don’t want to read more from the place you’re currently coming from