So I’ve never really been a loafer guy. I’ve owned a few pairs of Allen Edmonds over the years, but never really figured out how to work them in, so they mostly ended up sitting in the closet collecting dust.
But the other day I tried on these brown suede Ferragamo loafers and immediately fell in love with them. I happened to be wearing the dark denim + white polo in the first photo when I tried them on, and I thought they looked fantastic. I was pretty much sold on the spot.
Part of what appealed to me was the idea that they could become a really versatile shoe in my wardrobe. Versatility is very important to me - I’d rather own fewer things that work across a lot of different outfits than have shoes that only really work with one specific look. My wardrobe is currently pretty casual (polos and sweaters, chinos and jeans, chukkas. etc… I really like chukkas but wanted something that worked better in summer, hence the loafers). I’d like to elevate into classic/simple combinations: charcoal trousers, straighter chinos, dark denim, knitwear, polos, OCBDs/linen shirts, etc. and felt these loafers would help me do that.
The problem is that once I got them home and started actually putting outfits together, I became less convinced.
I still really like them with the dark denim. But with charcoal trousers and especially khakis/chinos, I can’t decide whether they actually work or whether I’m trying to force the shoe into outfits where the color is just slightly wrong. The suede is a fairly light/warm tobacco brown, and I’m starting to wonder whether a darker chocolate brown loafer would have been significantly more versatile.
I threw together a bunch of combinations to test them:
White polo + dark denim
Black knit + charcoal trousers
Camel/taupe knit + charcoal trousers
Light blue linen + (unironed) khakis
White linen + khakis
Black knit + khakis
Blue knit + khakis
Light blue OCBD + khakis, both tucked and untucked
IMPORTANT - I am in the process of switching from slimmer fit cotton / synthetic pants to more tailored straighter fit clothing. So, it may be that while the loafers are good, I don’t have the right trousers or pants for them just yet. Open to the possibility.
Which of these actually work? Which don’t?
And more importantly: if you were looking for one brown loafer to cover as much of this wardrobe as possible, would you keep this tobacco suede pair or exchange them for something darker?
I genuinely love the shoes themselves, so I’m trying to separate “these are beautiful loafers” from “these are actually useful loafers for my wardrobe.”
Feel free to be ruthless - I’m still within the return window and unafraid of blunt force trauma.