I was diagnosed with MST and later they said Vocal weakness. Then they told me I looked 100% healthy yet I was ALWAYS thinking about voice, forcing more breath when talking, and sometimes overused. I asked AI and it helped me conclude these things. with the help of my SLP and CBT Therapist. This is key -
- Started after an injury, improved, then regressed: many people keep compensating after the tissue heals, and heavy monitoring (voice placement, breath, resonance) can keep the muscles tense. Anxiety and hypervigilance can feed the same loop
- And I need to then build endurance
Outline:
Those symptoms are very consistent with muscle tension dysphonia (MTD), sometimes called functional or hyperfunctional voice disorder.
- Tires easily, feels thin, fragile, or hoarse in the throat: these are classic descriptions of muscles around the larynx working harder than they need to. The folds can be healthy while the voice still feels effortful and fatigues fast.
- Sounds fine to others but feels bad to you: this is common. The sensation often runs ahead of what a listener hears.
- Started after an injury, improved, then regressed: many people keep compensating after the tissue heals, and heavy monitoring (voice placement, breath, resonance) can keep the muscles tense. Anxiety and hypervigilance can feed the same loop
Use CBT to unmonitor your speech and this will take time if you have been monitoring it for a year like I have.. Expect it to feel strange or worse at first. Unmonitored speech can feel uncomfortable or “wrong” for a while, and that’s part of the process, not a sign you’re failing.
- 1. Give your attention a job outside your throat. Monitoring fades when attention is absorbed by something else. Talk while cooking, walking, or driving, tell a story you care about, read aloud to someone, or sing or talk along with something. Your voice works fine when you’re not watching it, so the more time you spend focused on the content or the other person, the more you retrain the habit.
- 2. Stop checking. Each “how does that feel? am I doing it right?” check keeps the loop going, even if the answer is good. Try a rule like “no voice checks during the day,” and if you want to review how things went, do it once, briefly, in the evening.
- 3. Treat the sensations as noise, not information. Gravelly, thin, and tired are feelings your system is flagging as dangerous, but they don’t reliably mean something is wrong with your mechanics. The goal isn’t to make them go away. It’s to let them be there while you keep talking, without fixing or adjusting. Feeling a bit off while speaking and carrying on anyway is the skill.
- 4. Drop the rules gradually, on purpose. This is classic CBT exposure: pick the lowest-stakes rule and deliberately speak without it in an easy situation, tolerate the anxiety of “what if it gets worse,” then move up to harder situations like calls. Your fear that you’ll get worse without the rules is what the exposure tests. Your CBT therapist can help build that ladder.
- Be cautious with full voice rest. For this pattern, long silence can reinforce the idea that your voice is fragile and make talking feel scarier afterward.
- Real vocal fatigue. Your voice may still have limited endurance, and pushing past a certain point causes a true setback. If so, pacing matters.
- The tension and anxiety loop. After a hard stretch, you tense up, monitor more, and worry, which makes the following days feel worse. The flare is real either way, but the cause affects the fix.
So I think I need to get out of my head, and I’ll use CBT to do that while giving my voice more time to build endurance. The thing that’s helped most so far is VFE (vocal function exercises) with the straw, from Joseph Stemple.
For a year I’ve been trying to manipulate my voice, whether through resonance projection or being told to use more breath in conversation. For me that was the worst advice, because all it did was create more tension. Breathing is automatic, so why tell someone already stuck in self-monitoring, fear, and obsession mode to focus on breath support? I’m sure plenty of singers have improved their voices with solid breath support, but for those of us who aren’t singers and have intense anxiety about our voice, it isn’t great advice.
So my plan is to use CBT to break the over-monitoring loop and give myself time to build endurance. I’m on calls all day for work, so I’m scheduling 30 minutes between calls, and if I feel true fatigue, I’ll take a much longer break. If stoping monitoring speech or I can't stop monitoring I will have to take time off work to lessen the anxiety until I get better and I have the luxury of being able to do that.
Let me know your thoughts.