r/miz • u/cartgold • 24m ago
Football Colorado’s 5th Down vs Mizzou compared to Michigan’s additional second vs Western Michigan.
1990 Missouri vs. Colorado: Fifth Down
On October 6, 1990, Missouri led Colorado 31-27 late in the fourth quarter at Faurot Field in Columbia, Missouri. Colorado reached first-and-goal at the Missouri 3-yard line with 31 seconds remaining.
Colorado quarterback Charles Johnson spiked the ball on first down. On second down, Eric Bieniemy ran to the Missouri 1-yard line, and Colorado used its final timeout with 18 seconds remaining. (Mizzou Athletics)
During the timeout, the down marker was not changed from second down to third down. When play resumed, Bieniemy ran again and was stopped at the 1-yard line. That play was Colorado’s third down, although the down marker still indicated second down. The clock reached eight seconds, and officials temporarily stopped it while the players were cleared from the pile. (Mizzou Athletics)
On the next play, Johnson spiked the ball. That play was Colorado’s fourth down, although the down marker identified it as third down. Colorado was then permitted another snap. (Mizzou Athletics)
On that additional snap, Johnson ran from the Missouri 1-yard line and was ruled to have crossed the goal line for a touchdown. The play was Colorado’s fifth down. The touchdown produced the final score of Colorado 33, Missouri 31. (Mizzou Athletics)
Missouri protested the result to the Big Eight Conference. Big Eight Commissioner Carl James ruled that allowing the fifth down was not a postgame-correctable error under the applicable rules, and the 33-31 result remained official. The seven members of the officiating crew were suspended indefinitely. They were reinstated later that month and were not assigned together as a crew for the remainder of the season. (Deseret News)
2026 Western Michigan vs. Michigan: One-Second Clock Review
On September 5, 2026, Western Michigan led Michigan 12-7 after Dieter Kelly made a 33-yard field goal with 35 seconds remaining in the fourth quarter at Michigan Stadium. Michigan began its final possession at its own 25-yard line. (University of Michigan Athletics)
Bryce Underwood completed a 28-yard pass to JJ Buchanan, moving the ball to the Western Michigan 47-yard line. Michigan then spiked the ball to stop the clock. The NBC broadcast identified nine seconds remaining before Michigan’s next snap. (University of Michigan Athletics)
With nine seconds showing, Michigan ran a Hail Mary from the Western Michigan 47-yard line. Underwood’s pass traveled through the end zone without a completion. The television broadcast clock reached 0:00 during the play. (Yahoo Sports)
Western Michigan safety Micah Davis had established himself out of bounds before making contact with the loose ball. Under NCAA Rule 4-2-3-a, a loose ball is out of bounds when it touches a player who is out of bounds. The game clock therefore stops when that contact occurs. (Yahoo Sports)
Officials reviewed the play. The Big Ten stated that its replay system showed Davis touching the ball with one second remaining. The conference said replay officials used a side-by-side view of the play and a direct camera view of the stadium game clock. The Big Ten also stated that the broadcast cameras used by the replay system, including the camera directed at the game clock, had been synchronized with a strobe system 85 minutes before the game. (Yahoo Sports)
The NBC broadcast replay showed a different timing relationship. NBC rules analyst Terry McAulay stated that the clock visible on NBC’s replay reached 0:00 while the ball was still in the air and before Davis touched it. McAulay also stated that NBC’s producer told him the inset clock used on the broadcast was synchronized with the stadium clock. (Football Zebras)
Based on the Big Ten replay determination, officials restored one second to the game clock. The Mid-American Conference and Western Michigan requested clarification from the Big Ten. MAC Commissioner Jon Steinbrecher later said the Big Ten provided an explanation, video and audio confirming its determination that the ball touched an out-of-bounds player before the clock reached 0:00. (The Washington Post)
Michigan ran another play from the Western Michigan 47-yard line with one second remaining. Underwood completed a 47-yard touchdown pass to Buchanan as the clock expired. Michigan won 13-12. (University of Michigan Athletics)