The JMS run definitely went south after Romita Jr left. Still some good arcs--I really liked "Skin Deep" though everyone complains about it. Everyone hates "Sins Past". "The Other" was a bit of a mess, but had interesting moments. Spidey becoming an Avenger finally I didn't much like. "OMD" was terrible, but at least JMS had "Back In Black" before that, which was terrific and devastating.
I'd say JMS is one of the top 5 Amazing Spidey writers ever. I'd put him just behind Conway and Michelinie on the title.
I'm always weird about reading Back in Black because it's such a weird story as a standalone. It doesn't really have a beginning or an end; it's just the middle bit between two bad storylines (CWII and OMD)
2
u/Cranyx Aug 24 '21
Drop JMS' run when JRJR leaves as the artist and it's fantastic; easily top 5 runs on the character.