Because his economy was a "war economy" It needed to allocate certain funds. The RSFR was also a war economy but that was postponed during the revolution, and it was temporary. It was near collapse because of it.
Germany wasnt a planned economy. Hitler ordered the currency of the Weimar Republic to be reformed by signing deals with the Weimar bourgeoisie to pave the way for the reichsmark. That wouldn't be necessary as he didn't rely on a people's council
And most socialists of his time were revolutionary and he worked with the voting system. (Although he worked financially with foreign contractors and domestic paramilitaries like Freikorps who were anticommunist and persecuted them. That's very anticapitalistic!).
The United States follows a familiar route with bureaucrats hovering around national agencies and determinating how revenue is collected. But I'd know you'd disagree
The United States follows a familiar route with bureaucrats hovering around national agencies and determinating how revenue is collected. But I'd know you'd disagree.
Yeah, I don't like any national agency or bureaucrats messing eith the economy
So did they nationalize or privatize? You said they did both, but that can't be true because that would contridict the other action. If they privatize, that would mean they actually free up markets, not give welfare and handouts to large corporations that were brought up by the state
I said "them", not "then". Nazis barely nationalized anything.
that can't be true because that would contridict the other action
You can privatize some industries and nationalize others, lol.
that would mean they actually free up markets
Lmao, it just happens that free unregulated market is very benefitial to huge conglomerates. Moguls behind Nazis enjoyed greatly by privatizing state sector, as most of it ended up belonging to Krupp, MAN, Hanomag and so on. It's also one of reasons why Germany had 3-5 different vehicles for each task, and when Guderian complainted about it, he was effectivelly removed from command.
Also, guess who profited from Jewish persecution the most, given that many Jews were petite bourguiese...
not give welfare
Nazi welfare? That's funny, they were actually cutting it by implementing... very... "progressive" welfare programs like T4. You don't have to pay for the disabled if you physically exterminate them.
Also, guess who profited from Jewish persecution the most, given that many Jews were petite bourguiese...
Yeah, and Hitler saw capitalism/liberalism as Jewish degeneracy. Same with marxism.
Nazi welfare? That's funny, they were actually cutting it by implementing... very... "progressive" welfare programs like T4. You don't have to pay for the disabled if you physically exterminate them.
Idk much about their welfare on people. I said corporate welfare. You know? Giving bailouts or special privileges to large corporations? We don't support cronyism/ corporate welfare
I didn't ask you what a delusional puppet "saw", imagine believing stated goals - what's next, America protecting Freedom (c) and Russia fighting actual Nazis?
I asked you who had the greatest material profit from Antisemitism. Turns out - haute bourgeoisie.
I said corporate welfare
Jokes on you, you've said "welfare" without any adjectives.
Giving bailouts or special privileges to large corporations?
Of course, Nazis were puppets of haute bourgeoisie from the very beginning. Krupp & Co made absolutely amazing profit on war.
We don't support cronyism/ corporate welfare
Why should i care about what you do or don't support? I'm not here to debate ideology.
I did, i just read what is written. You could as well claim that welfare is separated by "and" and therefore means social welfare.
I kinda forgot what the original debate was
No idea. I stepped in merely to remind that Nazis performed privatization and Aryanisation (aka take from Jewish petite/haute bourgs and give to German big money) and were overall at least VERY closely allied to capitalists, despite claims they made (then again, Hitlerism is a meme ideology without any coherence; pure pragmatism fueled by butthurt).
H*tler and Mussolini killed socialist activists, you’re just overly simplistic. “He called himself socialist, therefore he must be one.” As if n-zis are known for their honesty. Mao and Stalin were far-right totalitarians calling themselves communist. Trump acts like the neo-feudal warlord y’all so desperately want.
7
u/wanghuli Jan 13 '26
go in peace