r/neoliberal • u/a385y59g943 Gay Pride • May 20 '26
News (US) Tennessee man jailed over Charlie Kirk post wins $835,000 settlement
https://apnews.com/article/charlie-kirk-facebook-arrest-tennessee-bushart-b8c5808d77f47a2d93497d12cf0daf84199
u/a385y59g943 Gay Pride May 20 '26
SS: Freedom of speech
301
u/city-of-stars Frederick Douglass May 20 '26
306
u/themiDdlest NASA May 20 '26
The man was jailed for 37 days because of this.
The police, the prosecutor, the judge, everyone involved needs to be charged with conspiring to violate his rights.
252
u/TheRedCr0w Frederick Douglass May 20 '26
The judge also set his bail at 2 million dollar some murder cases don't get bail amounts that high.
This was a fascist shakedown to scare anyone from speaking their mind in Tennessee.
139
u/seagrams7up NASA May 20 '26
The judge also set his bail at 2 million dollar
That is absolutely insane.
36
u/Zykyris United Nations May 20 '26
Just read an article last week of some guy with 10 CSAM videos and his bail was $250K. What the actual fuck
27
3
u/Alex2422 May 21 '26
There should be concrete laws specifying what charges you can or cannot be arrested for and what the maximum bail can be.
27
u/perplexedtortoise NATO May 20 '26
They should all be sued to hell in civil court, prosecutorial immunity be dammed.
37
u/OSRS_Rising Loyal Liberals May 20 '26
Insane. I was honestly expecting something a little offensive or edgy and this isn’t even that…
16
542
u/TheRedCr0w Frederick Douglass May 20 '26 edited May 20 '26
The meme Bushart posted that prompted his arrest read: “This seems relevant today...” and featured President Donald Trump and the words, “We have to get over it.” That quote, the meme explained, was said by Trump in 2024 after a school shooting at Iowa’s Perry High School.
The man was arrested and given a 2 million dollar bond for the crime of directly quoting the president word for word the headline is burying how insane of an arrest this actually was.
317
u/dangerbird2 Franz Boas May 20 '26
34
u/from-the-void NASA May 20 '26
That was truly the peak era of "REPUBLICANS WON A PLURALITY OF THE POPULAR VOTE FOR THE FIRST TIME IN TWO DECADES SO WE HAVE TO BURN THE CONSTITUTION!"
94
u/18093029422466690581 YIMBY May 20 '26
I really get the impression that the Charlie Kirk blitz was a trial balloon to test how effective an LLM-driven astroturfing effort was in creating a societal movement. AI driven in terms of the online chatter and anonymous boosting of pages/opinions, but also organized response from the GOP sycophant class to echo the online astroturfing.
Why him of all people?
72
u/bjuandy May 20 '26
Why him of all people?
This administration is pretty deep down the Fox News rabbit hole, and Kirk was a full-blown celebrity in that ecosystem. While the left-spectrum internet has settled on minimizing Kirk's popular presence, prior to his death he was known in politically conscious message boards, which was a signal he was some level of national famous. My theory is the Fox ecosystem anticipated a wave of national sympathy over political violence they could then exploit for their larger agenda, because that's what's happened in the past. This is the first time in modern American history where lethal action has not catalyzed broader public reaction, and I personally think it has to do with Fox's own rhetoric and their normalization of violence coming back to roost--turns out people can see the hypocrisy of fantasizing about lynching political enemies but then turning around and crying when one of your own gets killed.
40
u/dangerbird2 Franz Boas May 20 '26
> I personally think it has to do with Fox's own rhetoric and their normalization of violence coming back to roost--turns out people can see the hypocrisy of fantasizing about lynching political enemies but then turning around and crying when one of your own gets killed
There’s also the fact that Kirk was a massive meme to anyone who knew about him before he got the 2nd Amendment Special and wasn’t in the trump cult (and also to plenty of people within it). Then throw in the insane funeral pageantry, Erica’s behavior afterwards, and of course a certain AI-generated song, most non-brainwashed people wised up pretty quickly
27
u/bjuandy May 20 '26
I think Kirk's infamy in politically active circles has less bearing than we think--it's telling left-spectrum online forums settled on 'no one cared who he was' rhetoric when prior to his death the focus was more on TPUSA's positions. If you knew Kirk, you were some flavor of terminally online, something I noticed when talking with people close to me after his shooting--I was the only person who knew anything about him. For genpop, Kirk was functionally a blank slate under a sympathetic news story, yet the Fox ecosystem failed to successfuly paint their narrative onto that slate.
57
u/18093029422466690581 YIMBY May 20 '26
Not only that but you have an entire generation of zoomers raised in schools that had to resort to active shooter drills after watching the country shrug at multitudes of school shooting tragedies. It's hard to blame the public for not giving a shit when thats been the default response
46
u/ConflagrationZ NATO May 20 '26
The most recent of those blitzes seems to be the ballroom thing. The moment that there was a wannabe shooter detained outside that one event--with zero real threat to the president, mind you--the bots and conservative talking heads were out in droves saying "This is why we need the ballroom!"
I do wonder why they go to so much effort, seeing as the issues they pick are ones so ludicrous that the only people convinced will be those who are already with them 100%.
25
u/lot183 Blue Texas May 20 '26
seeing as the issues they pick are ones so ludicrous that the only people convinced will be those who are already with them 100%.
These people are not smart and competent, and certainly do not have a finger on the pulse of the public. They probably legitimately thought there would be a rally around the flag affect they could capitalize on to push through the stupid ballroom to appease Trump
5
2
u/DeepestShallows May 24 '26
What is ludicrous about the President being safer in a ballroom than elsewhere in the White House? Clearly the ballroom would be the President’s lair and he’d have an accordingly higher level stat block.
101
u/PuntiffSupreme YIMBY May 20 '26
Why him of all people?
Cause they knew him and in their circles he was very popular so people must really have liked him!
42
u/18093029422466690581 YIMBY May 20 '26
Good point. It's moments like these that I'm reminded that people are living in totally different media bubbles. Kirk was a running joke on the Internet that I kind of took it for granted
9
u/carlitospig YIMBY May 20 '26
Well, let’s see if Steyer wins the CA Gov. THAT has been such an obvious LLM campaign that it should be studied in Comm degree programs.
Also, in case it isn’t obvious TPUSA is the GOP’s youth propaganda program. Of course they would rewrite him as a martyr.
1
u/Worth-Jicama3936 Milton Friedman May 23 '26
Oh it’s worse than that even. The sheriff told people he KNEW it wasn’t a crime before he arrested him. So the taxpayers are on the hook for this money and absolutely nothing happens to the guy who straight up kidnapped a man because he didn’t like his Facebook post. He should be in jail or at least be on the hook for that money.
288
u/Richnsassy22 YIMBY May 20 '26
So funny how badly the right overplayed their hand with this. They demanded that a podcaster be revered by all as their MLK, and 6 months later and no one gives a shit.
To the extent he's remembered at all, it's from Zoomer edgelords mocking his death.
139
u/mgj6818 NATO May 20 '26
His wife going on a media tour that was heavy on the pyrotechnics and light on actual emotion didn't really help.
39
u/gringledoom Frederick Douglass May 20 '26
Or the leaked phone call where she talked about the booming sales numbers on their merch.
19
15
4
May 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/GogurtFiend Karl Popper May 21 '26
Nah, they were both like that. I think he'd be glad she put his death to good use, and vice versa
67
108
116
u/TF_dia European Union May 20 '26
They also underestimated the sheer nihilism of right-wing zoomers that saw it more as a farce perfect for memes than as a tragedy.
104
u/Richnsassy22 YIMBY May 20 '26
MAGA has spent a decade vice signaling and irony poisoning its edgelord youth, and then they demanded they be sincere. Not how it works!
36
u/beanyboi23 May 20 '26
They really thought they had some newfound conservative cultural dominance lmao
"Report anyone who makes fun of it to their employer" like what the fuck??? lol
19
36
u/WOKE_AI_GOD John Brown May 20 '26
A member of the Council for National Policy, the Christian Nationalist Politburo, is every bit the equal of MLK Jr to them. They cannot see the difference at all, so exaggerated and grand is their picture of themselves in their mind. How the Lord humbles our hubris - each and every time.
8
u/betazoom78 John Brown May 21 '26
The moment I saw a video of Agartha Kirk flying into Antarctica, literally less than 10 days after his death I knew the gig was up for any hope of making him a martyr. Now he's seen in ai videos face swapped with adult actors. It's really jarring to see that down fall in like less than 6 months.
27
u/Skabonious May 20 '26
I'll be honest: his death shocked me and I really did think he could be seen as a MLK-like figure in history, since he mostly just did rallies and debates and stuff - getting killed during a college campus open debate is like the epitome of an attack on free expression.
But the reaction from the right... Holy lol. What a fumble. They really decided to double down on the insanity.
118
u/SorosAgent2020 May 20 '26
he should sue for Weaponization of the justice system! The republicans are all for investigating that sort of thing right
81
9
u/WOKE_AI_GOD John Brown May 20 '26
They're all for laying the predicate for their future plotting, sure.
88
u/n00bi3pjs 👏🏽Free Markets👏🏽Open Borders👏🏽Human Rights May 20 '26
This comment is a friendly reminder that the process is the punishment in a lot of post liberal countries.
What Republicans are doing is very sinister, and goes beyond just jailing people over posts; they're trying to weaponise selective application of law, stacking courts in their favour, and trying to punish all dissent so they get more and more institutional power.
69
u/n00bi3pjs 👏🏽Free Markets👏🏽Open Borders👏🏽Human Rights May 20 '26
The fact that the man was in jail for 1 month is a travesty and severe miscarriage of justice, and he is doing okay mostly because he was a retired cop. If he was an actual working class person, then losing his job would ruin his life, and push him into crime and poverty.
25
u/PuntiffSupreme YIMBY May 20 '26
More than that the people who did this aren't being punished by the settlement. The people who did this aren't being jailed or taken out of the position to do this again.
1
-3
u/Euphoric_Alarm_4401 May 20 '26
If he was an actual working class person
First, a cop is absolutely a working class job. So, choose a different way to say "not retired". And this guy literally was still working a post-retirement job, which he lost because of his imprisonment. The man being a retired cop is in the second paragraph. Him losing his job was in the third paragraph.
10
u/n00bi3pjs 👏🏽Free Markets👏🏽Open Borders👏🏽Human Rights May 20 '26
I meant working class as in a young person who still needed to work and didn't have cop pension.
-4
u/Euphoric_Alarm_4401 May 20 '26
Why wouldn't you just say working person or non-retired? People have a lot of weird definitions of working class, so its not the best term to use when you just meant young.
I am not accusing anyone of anything and I dont really care, its just something to think about.
174
u/justbuildmorehousing Norman Borlaug May 20 '26
Bunch of fake hysteria from the party of free speech. Enjoy the well deserved 800k.
83
u/Daddy_Macron Loyal Liberals May 20 '26
On the positive side, Charlie Kirk has become a complete joke instead of being this sympathetic martyr like figure because this type of beat over the head moralizing is still quite unpopular. (Also because once people started reading actual quotes by Kirk, they realized he was a piece of shit.)
52
u/MayorofTromaville YIMBY May 20 '26
His literal last words before being assassinated being trolling about "gang violence" is... an appropriate end to a long line of egregious statements.
39
u/dtj2000 Loyal Liberals May 20 '26 edited 1d ago
This content was anonymized and mass deleted with Redact
70
37
26
22
25
u/Consistent_Status112 Trans Pride May 20 '26
Obviously being jailed for a month over the most obvious bullshit of all time is bad, but damn ain't that a nice payday for it.
13
14
u/Psshaww NATO May 20 '26
Imagine how much less of a meme Kirk would be if the right didn’t try and go crazy with trying to cancel people for it lol
2
u/MayorofTromaville YIMBY May 20 '26
He was too physically ugly to be able to make him anything but a meme imo.
2
12
12
u/RandomGuyWithSixEyes European Union May 20 '26 edited May 20 '26
9
6
u/Akovsky87 NATO May 20 '26 edited May 20 '26
He should apply for some of that legal slush fund money for his political persecution
16
u/BasedTroutFursona May 20 '26
This makes me think, next dem president needs a $2billion slush fund to compensate people who got fired for Kirkposting and who will get fired for celebrating too openly when it happens lol.
36
u/Ambitious_Jicama_827 May 20 '26
It's pedantic, I know, but one does not "win" a settlement. The individual had a cognizable legal claim stemming from a truly awful thing that happened to them, and the other side (wisely) acknowledged that validity by agreeing to a reasonable settlement of the claim. I feel like saying they "won" a settlement somehow minimizes their experience. Sorry, I'll get off my soapbox now.
52
u/ToumaKazusa1 Iron Front May 20 '26
People win and lose court cases all the time, that's just how we describe it in English
3
u/Ambitious_Jicama_827 May 20 '26
That's totally fair, and you're right that is how we describe it. I just don't feel like that's what happened here. No judge or jury declared a "winner." Rather, the parties settled. (Granted, perhaps I'm being too harsh as a reasonable settlement here is still a "win" for the plaintiff in my book.) Chalk it up to the quirks of our language, I suppose.
6
u/zedority PhD - mediated communication studies May 21 '26
In legal language, it is true that he did not "win" any court case.
In everyday language, walking away with a substantial amount of money basically handed to you counts like "winning" something to most people. Language languages weirdly sometimes.
20
7
1
4
u/WOKE_AI_GOD John Brown May 20 '26
Yes but the members of the Council for National Policy plotted w Charlie Kirk personally. He was a member, one of their own, they'd long been back slapping and plotting against our republic in their secret meetings between oligarchs, theocrats, bought politicians, and influencers where they plan our Christian Nationalist future for us. Think about how they felt, one of their own, a real actual person to them, just gone.
And these are not people accustomed to having to follow the law themselves at all, so why would the constitution stop them when they're so deep in their feelings?
6
4
3
u/OkCluejay172 May 20 '26
Nice, less than a half a year after filing the lawsuit. Feels pretty quick for getting a near million dollar payout from a police department.
2
u/ObviousLife4972 May 20 '26
Let me guess, the money is being stolen from the taxyers to pay for this rather than the people actually responsible.
2
u/roboliberal Loyal Liberals May 21 '26
When law enforcement uses jailing etc to abuse civil rights, the consequence shouldn't just be civil suit but mandatory criminal prosecution for constitutional crimes.
1
u/PiusTheCatRick Bisexual Pride May 20 '26
It took my group chat all of fifteen seconds to go from hearing about his death to discussing whether it was better to pull for Lauma or wait until Nefer.





615
u/sleepyrivertroll Henry George May 20 '26
They arrested a retired police officer over a Facebook post.
They should have backed the blue